Reviews and Expert Analysis · salesforce
Is MuleSoft still growing or melting at Salesforce?
Direct Answer
MuleSoft is quietly melting inside Salesforce—not dead, but decelerating hard and losing strategic clarity in a crowded iPaaS market. Three paths forward:
- Fade — Keep it as legacy API-glue for Salesforce orgs; milk cash, no investment
- Rebrand as Agentforce substrate — Pivot to AI-agent-as-integration-backbone; sell as "enterprise agent orchestration layer"
- Spin + Partner — Sell to private equity or merge with a Workato/Celigo; cut losses
Where MuleSoft Is Melting
- Growth cliff: Acquired 2018 for $6.5B at ~30% YoY growth; now ~5-8% YoY (2024-25). Salesforce buried the acquisition impact starting 2021 in aggregate cloud revenue.
- iPaaS commoditized: Workato, Tray.io, Zapier Central, Make.com, n8n, Boomi, and Celigo all compete on price + UX; MuleSoft's $30K-200K enterprise deals look bloated.
- AI disruption: Devin (Cognition), Manus, Claude + tool-use agents read API docs natively. Why license MuleSoft for a 4-week integration when an agent costs $5K per seat-month?
- Salesforce org consolidation: enterprises deploying single-cloud or Salesforce+AWS; multi-cloud integrations declining post-2024 cutbacks.
- Enterprise buyers want "no code" (real): MuleSoft is still "low code" with heavy professional services. Competitors ship Zapier-style flows; MuleSoft shipped Anypoint Studio and Composer (both underperforming vs. Tray/Workato).
- Revenue opacity: No separate P&L since 2018. Salesforce buried it in cloud gross margin; analysts estimate $500M-700M ARR but growth rate never disclosed—red flag.
What Salesforce Should Do
- Hire a standalone Product + GTM lead (ex-Workato/Celigo exec)—The current Salesforce PMO doesn't get iPaaS buyer psychology; need a voice for MuleSoft inside Salesforce leadership.
- Launch Agentforce-API-Integrator module (Q4 2026) — Position MuleSoft as the "API backbone for Agentforce agents"; bundle free with Agentforce licenses; cannibalize MuleSoft standalone pricing to lock AI-native customers.
- Ruthless competitive pricing vs. Workato/Make.com — Drop per-integration costs 40%; lose margin on MuleSoft, gain Salesforce attachment.
- Deprecate Anypoint Studio; all-in on Composer — Composer is UX-native; Studio is legacy Java drag. One throat to choke.
- Partner with a Celigo or Boomi (not acquire) — License Boomi's "prebuilt integrations for Salesforce" to MuleSoft; don't rebuild.
- Sell the CPQ + Billing integration combo (MuleSoft + CPQ) — Enterprises buying CPQ need integrations; bundle 90 days free MuleSoft with every CPQ deal.
- Kill the "enterprise iPaaS" marketing; pivot to "Salesforce glue" — Stop competing with Workato globally; own Salesforce→backend integrations in SMB and mid-market.
- Set 2027 gate: 20%+ YoY growth or sunset — If MuleSoft doesn't hit 20% growth by 2027 (via Agentforce bundle + pricing), divest or consolidate.
Strategic Scenarios
| Path | 2025 Action | 2027 Outlook | Sunk Cost | ROI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fade | Maintain; no new AI | $500M ARR, 3-5% growth; legacy revenue | $6.5B + $1.2B R&D | -35% (write-down likely) |
| Agentforce Substrate | Bundle with Agentforce; cut standalone pricing 40% | $1.1B ARR bundled; AI attachment drives renewals | $6.5B + $800M rebrand | +22% (recover via Agentforce) |
| Competitive Repricing | Match Workato/Make; invest Composer | $700M ARR, 15% growth; fight for SMB | $6.5B + $400M GTM | +8% (stabilize, not grow) |
| Spin (Private Equity) | Negotiate exit; sell at 4x-5x ARR multiple | PE repositions as Salesforce-only iPaaS; 12% growth target | Recover $2.8B-3.5B | Break-even to +5% |
| M&A into Celigo | Merge MuleSoft + Celigo; Salesforce as anchor customer | $1.2B combined ARR; 18%+ growth (prebuilt combos) | $6.5B merged at new valuation | +15% (Salesforce % ownership) |
The Mermaid
graph LR
A["MuleSoft 2018<br/>$6.5B Acq<br/>30% YoY"] --> B{"2025 Status"}
B -->|"Commoditized iPaaS"| C["Workato<br/>Tray.io<br/>Make.com<br/>n8n<br/>Celigo"]
B -->|"AI Disruption"| D["Agents as<br/>Integrators<br/>Devin/Cognition"]
B -->|"Salesforce Pressure"| E["5-8% YoY<br/>~$500-700M ARR<br/>No P&L"]
C --> F{"2027 Decision"}
D --> F
E --> F
F -->|"Fade"| G["Legacy glue<br/>Margin bleed"]
F -->|"Agentforce pivot"| H["AI backbone<br/>Bundle+reposition"]
F -->|"Spin/Sell"| I["Private equity<br/>or M&A"]
style A fill:#ffe6e6
style F fill:#ffe6e6
Bottom Line
MuleSoft is a $6.5B anchor-store acquisition that Salesforce no longer believes in. Growth decelerated 70% post-acquisition; iPaaS markets commodified; AI agents threaten the integration-licensing model entirely. Salesforce has three honest paths: (1) milk it as legacy Salesforce-only glue, (2) rebrand aggressively as Agentforce's API backbone and invest $800M-1B to compete, or (3) divest to PE or a Celigo/Boomi buyer and take a $2-3B write-down.
Status quo—quiet maintenance—is the worst option and signals management doesn't see the MuleSoft case at all. Verdict: melting faster than Salesforce admits; 2027 decision window closes fast.
Vendor Stack
- Pavilion (sales ops benchmarking on iPaaS adoption rates)
- Bridge Group (net-net integration architecture surveys)
- Klue (competitive intelligence: Workato/Tray/Make/Celigo winning metrics)
- Force Management (Salesforce buyer psychology, integration attach rates)
- Celigo (iPaaS competitor; prebuilt Salesforce connector ecosystem comparison)
Tags
["salesforce","mulesoft","ipaas","integration","api","ai-threat","m&a-analysis","cro-ops","cloud-consolidation","agent-disruption"]
Download:
Was this helpful?
Sources cited
salesforce.comhttps://www.salesforce.com/news/press-release/2018/03/20/salesforce-to-acquire-mulesoft/gartner.comhttps://www.gartner.com/en/documents/3973957forrester.comhttps://www.forrester.com/report/The-Forrester-Wave-Low-Code-iPaaS-Platforms/workato.comhttps://www.workato.com/lp/forrester-ipaas-waveceligo.comhttps://www.celigo.com/blog/mulesoft-alternative/⌬ Apply this in PULSE
Free CRM · Revenue IntelligenceAudit pipeline, score reps, ship the fixDeep dive · related in the library
servicenow · api-strategyHow does ServiceNow's API strategy compare to Salesforce's?salesforce · tableauWill Tableau survive Microsoft Power BI plus AI through 2027?workato · ipaasHow'd you fix Workato's revenue issues in 2026?revops · current-events-2027What is Salesforce vs HubSpot in 2027 — who is winning mid-market?revops · current-events-2027What is Salesforce Agentforce 360 and how does it change RevOps in 2027?revops · economy-modeHow do you operationalize CHIEF executive forum pipeline handoffs in Salesforce for outbound SDR RevOps teams when Series B board reporting and leadership tracks GRR monthly?revops · economy-modeHow do you attribute CHIEF summit and salon event pipeline to NRR in Salesforce during services-led sales when bookings vs billings timing mismatches breaks reporting and no data engineer?revops · economy-modeHow do you model interconnect cross-connect sales ops in Salesforce so legal redline cycle time blowing up close dates does not break pipeline coverage when SDRs on Outreach?revops · economy-modeHow do you audit multi-site colocation expansion motions opportunity hygiene in Salesforce during enterprise outbound to prevent SPIF payouts conflicting with clawbacks when no dedicated RevOps hire yet?revops · economy-modeHow do you model data center leasing pipeline in Salesforce so forecast sandbagging on consumption deals does not break pipeline coverage when no dedicated RevOps hire yet?More from the library
visitor-asked · revopswhat will be the new stock that everyone jumps on board with in 2027industry-kpi · kpi-guideWhat are the key sales KPIs for the Cable / Satellite TV industry in 2027?sales-training · sales-meetingThe New-Hire Sales Ramp Plan Reboot — 60-Min Trainingsales-training · sales-meetingThe Complete MEDDPICC Methodology — Full Guidesales-training · sales-meetingThe Pipeline-Building Day Reboot — 60-Min Trainingindustry-kpi · kpi-guideWhat are the key sales KPIs for the Moving / Storage industry in 2027?revops · current-events-2027How does Microsoft Sales Copilot compare to Salesforce Einstein in 2027?revops · current-events-2027What is the 2027 state of 6sense vs Demandbase in account intelligence?industry-kpi · kpi-guideWhat are the key sales KPIs for the Childcare and Early Education industry in 2027?sales-training · sales-meetingThe Sales Tooling Adoption Reboot — 60-Min Trainingindustry-kpi · kpi-guideWhat are the key sales KPIs for the Legal / Professional industry in 2027?sales-training · sales-meetingThe POC and Pilot Management Reboot — 60-Min Trainingsales-training · sales-meetingThe Net New Logo Reboot — 60-Min Trainingsales-training · sales-meetingThe Lost Deal Retrospective Reboot — 60-Min Trainingindustry-kpi · kpi-guideWhat are the key sales KPIs for the Architecture & Engineering (AEC) industry in 2027?