Pulse Reviews and Analysis
Top 10 Private High Schools in Indianapolis
Curated by Chief Revenue Officer Kory White · CRO Syndicate
Top 10 Private High Schools in Indianapolis
Direct Answer
The Best Overall private high school in the Indianapolis area is Park Tudor School, a non-sectarian college-preparatory school on the city's north side whose small classes, deep AP catalog, and near-universal four-year-college matriculation place it at the top of Indiana's private schools.
The Best Value pick is Bishop Chatard High School, a Catholic college-prep school whose strong outcomes and active financial-aid program deliver private-school rigor at a tuition well below the elite independent schools. This list is built for Indianapolis-area families and students weighing where to enroll, with a focus on academics, college outcomes, and fit.
Every pick uses real, publicly reported data from U.S. News, Niche, the Indiana Department of Education, and individual schools.
How We Ranked the Top 10
We weighted each school against the priorities families consistently rank highest, drawing on published figures from U.S. News, Niche, GreatSchools, individual schools, and the College Board. The weighting:
- Academic performance (test scores, AP/IB) - 25%
- College and post-grad outcomes - 20%
- Value, tuition, and aid - 15%
- Teachers and resources - 15%
- Environment and safety - 15%
- Extracurriculars and fit - 10%
A school that posts elite reputation but thin programs, or charges premium tuition without the outcomes to match, drops fast. The winners balance rigor, outcomes, support, and value.
1. Park Tudor School 🏆 BEST OVERALL
Type: Private, Non-sectarian, College Prep | Tuition: Roughly \$25,000 per year (upper school) | Best for: Families wanting the metro's most rigorous independent college-prep education
On the north side of Indianapolis, Park Tudor School enrolls about 1,000 students across all grades and is widely regarded as the premier independent college-preparatory school in the metro. The upper school posts near-universal four-year-college matriculation, a deep AP catalog, and small classes with a student-teacher ratio near 8:1.
Park Tudor's graduates regularly attend the most selective universities in the country, and its athletics, arts, and academic-team programs are competitive statewide. The school combines academic rigor with strong college counseling.
Pros:
- Near-universal four-year-college matriculation
- Deep AP catalog with small, seminar-style classes
- Student-teacher ratio near 8:1
- Strong college counseling and selective-college outcomes
Cons:
- High tuition typical of elite independent schools
- Competitive academic environment
Verdict: Park Tudor wins on balance - the most rigorous independent college-prep education in the metro.
2. Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School
Type: Private, Catholic (Jesuit), College Prep | Tuition: Roughly \$19,000 per year | Best for: Families wanting Jesuit values with strong college-prep academics
Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School in Indianapolis enrolls about 800 students and pairs Jesuit educational values with rigorous college preparation. The school posts strong four-year-college matriculation, an extensive AP and Advanced Placement Capstone program, and a culture of service and reflection central to Jesuit education.
Brebeuf's arts, athletics, and academic programs are well regarded, and its welcoming, mission-driven community draws families across the metro. Robust financial aid broadens access.
Pros:
- Strong four-year-college matriculation
- Extensive AP and Capstone offerings
- Mission-driven Jesuit values and service culture
- Robust financial-aid program
Cons:
- Catholic identity may not fit every family
- Tuition is significant though below the elite tier
Verdict: The Jesuit standout - rigorous academics grounded in service and values.
3. Cathedral High School
Type: Private, Catholic, College Prep | Tuition: Roughly \$18,000 per year | Best for: Families wanting a large Catholic school with strong academics and athletics
Cathedral High School in Indianapolis enrolls about 1,200 students and is one of the metro's largest and most established Catholic college-prep schools. Cathedral reports strong four-year-college matriculation, a broad AP catalog, and powerhouse athletics across many sports.
The school's Holy Cross educational tradition, active campus ministry, and well-funded facilities support a comprehensive experience. Significant financial aid keeps the school accessible to a broad range of families.
Pros:
- Strong college matriculation and broad AP catalog
- Powerhouse athletics across many sports
- Established Holy Cross tradition and campus ministry
- Significant financial aid available
Cons:
- Larger enrollment than some peer Catholic schools
- Catholic identity may not fit every family
Verdict: The large Catholic-school leader - strong academics paired with elite athletics.
4. Bishop Chatard High School
Type: Private, Catholic, College Prep | Tuition: Roughly \$14,000 per year | Best for: Families seeking strong Catholic college prep at an accessible price 💎 BEST VALUE
Bishop Chatard High School in Indianapolis enrolls about 700 students and delivers strong Catholic college-prep outcomes at a tuition well below the elite independent schools, backed by an active financial-aid program that widens access further. Chatard reports strong four-year-college matriculation, a solid AP catalog, and well-regarded athletics and arts.
The smaller size supports close teacher relationships and a tight community, making it the metro's strongest outcomes-per-dollar private option.
Pros:
- Strong college matriculation at accessible tuition
- Active financial-aid program
- Solid AP catalog and competitive athletics
- Small, close-knit community
Cons:
- Smaller AP catalog than the largest schools
- Catholic identity may not fit every family
Verdict: The value champion - strong Catholic college prep at a fraction of elite-school cost.
5. The International School of Indiana
Type: Private, Non-sectarian, IB | Tuition: Roughly \$23,000 per year (upper school) | Best for: Families wanting a language-immersion, International Baccalaureate education
The International School of Indiana (ISI) in Indianapolis enrolls about 600 students and is the metro's leading International Baccalaureate (IB) school, with language-immersion programs in French, Spanish, and Mandarin from the early grades through the IB Diploma Programme in the upper school.
ISI's graduates earn the globally recognized IB diploma and matriculate to selective universities worldwide. The small classes, multilingual environment, and international focus are distinctive among metro private schools.
Pros:
- Full International Baccalaureate diploma pathway
- Language immersion in French, Spanish, and Mandarin
- Globally recognized credential and worldwide matriculation
- Small, multilingual, internationally focused community
Cons:
- High tuition and a demanding IB workload
- Smaller athletics program than larger schools
Verdict: The international standout - the metro's premier IB and language-immersion school.
6. Heritage Christian School
Type: Private, Christian, College Prep | Tuition: Roughly \$13,000 per year | Best for: Families wanting a faith-based college-prep education with strong programs
Heritage Christian School in Indianapolis enrolls a large student body across all grades and offers a Christian college-preparatory education with a broad AP catalog, strong arts and athletics, and solid four-year-college matriculation. The school pairs faith-integrated instruction with rigorous academics, and its sizable campus supports a wide range of extracurriculars.
Tuition sits below the elite independent tier, and financial aid is available, making it an accessible faith-based option.
Pros:
- Faith-integrated college-prep curriculum
- Broad AP catalog and strong arts and athletics
- Large campus with wide extracurricular range
- Accessible tuition with financial aid
Cons:
- Christian identity may not fit every family
- Less selective admission than the elite independents
Verdict: The faith-based leader - strong college prep with broad programs at an accessible price.
7. Roncalli High School
Type: Private, Catholic, College Prep | Tuition: Roughly \$13,000 per year | Best for: Southside families wanting Catholic college prep with strong athletics
Roncalli High School on the south side of Indianapolis enrolls about 1,100 students and is the leading Catholic college-prep school for the southside metro. Roncalli reports strong four-year-college matriculation, a solid AP catalog, and state-contending athletics programs.
The school's Catholic identity, active campus ministry, and tight community are central to its appeal, and an active financial-aid program keeps tuition accessible. Its scale supports a wide range of clubs and activities.
Pros:
- Strong college matriculation and solid AP catalog
- State-contending athletics programs
- Active Catholic community and campus ministry
- Financial aid keeps tuition accessible
Cons:
- Catholic identity may not fit every family
- Less program specialization than IB or elite independents
Verdict: The southside Catholic leader - strong academics and athletics in a tight community.
8. Guerin Catholic High School
Type: Private, Catholic, College Prep | Tuition: Roughly \$15,000 per year | Best for: Northern-suburb families wanting Catholic college prep
Guerin Catholic High School in Noblesville, serving the northern suburbs, enrolls about 800 students and offers a strong Catholic college-prep education with a solid AP catalog, competitive athletics, and strong four-year-college matriculation. The relatively new campus is well-resourced, and the school's Catholic mission and close community appeal to families in the fast-growing northern metro.
Financial aid broadens access for qualifying families.
Pros:
- Strong college matriculation and solid AP catalog
- Competitive athletics and a modern campus
- Catholic mission with a close community
- Financial aid available
Cons:
- Catholic identity may not fit every family
- Newer school with a shorter track record
Verdict: The northern-suburb Catholic standout - strong academics in a modern, mission-driven setting.
9. Lutheran High School of Indianapolis
Type: Private, Christian (Lutheran), College Prep | Tuition: Roughly \$11,000 per year | Best for: Families wanting an affordable, faith-based college-prep school
Lutheran High School of Indianapolis enrolls a few hundred students and offers a Lutheran Christian college-prep education at one of the more affordable private tuitions in the metro. The school pairs faith-integrated instruction with solid academics, a range of AP and dual-credit options, and active athletics and arts programs.
Its small size supports close teacher relationships, and financial aid widens access. For families seeking an affordable faith-based option, it is a strong fit.
Pros:
- Affordable faith-based college-prep tuition
- AP and dual-credit options
- Small, close-knit community
- Active athletics and arts programs
Cons:
- Smaller AP catalog than larger schools
- Christian identity may not fit every family
Verdict: The affordable faith-based choice - solid college prep at an accessible price.
10. Scecina Memorial High School
Type: Private, Catholic, College Prep | Tuition: Roughly \$11,000 per year | Best for: East-side families wanting accessible Catholic college prep
Scecina Memorial High School on the east side of Indianapolis enrolls a few hundred students and offers an accessible Catholic college-prep education with a focus on personal attention and community. The school reports solid four-year-college matriculation, offers AP and dual-credit coursework, and fields competitive athletics.
Its small size and active financial-aid program make private Catholic education attainable for east-side families who value a close, faith-based environment.
Pros:
- Accessible Catholic college-prep tuition with aid
- AP and dual-credit coursework
- Personal attention in a small community
- Competitive athletics
Cons:
- Smaller program and AP catalog
- Catholic identity may not fit every family
Verdict: The accessible east-side Catholic option - personal attention and faith-based college prep.
Which One's Right for You?
What to Look For When Choosing a Private High School
- College matriculation and outcomes - Ask where graduates actually enroll and what share attend four-year colleges, since real outcomes matter more than reputation.
- AP/IB depth and pass rates - Look at how many students take and pass advanced courses, not just how many are listed in the catalog.
- Tuition and financial aid - Compare net price after aid; schools like Bishop Chatard, Lutheran, and Scecina deliver strong outcomes well below the elite tier.
- Mission and identity fit - Decide whether a non-sectarian, Catholic, Jesuit, Lutheran, or international program matches the family's values before chasing prestige.
- Class size and teacher access - Smaller student-teacher ratios and strong advising shape a student's experience more than building age or marketing.
- Program fit - An IB diploma at the International School or a Jesuit service culture at Brebeuf may serve a specific student far better than a higher overall ranking.
What matters less than marketing implies: a school's name recognition, its newest building, or its tuition alone. Fit, outcomes, and a supportive teacher relationship affect a student's success far more than a single headline figure.
FAQ
Which private high school is the best overall in the Indianapolis area? Park Tudor School earns the top spot as the metro's premier independent college-prep school, with near-universal four-year-college matriculation, a deep AP catalog, and a student-teacher ratio near 8:1.
What is the best value private high school in Indianapolis? Bishop Chatard High School is our best value - it delivers strong Catholic college-prep outcomes at a tuition well below the elite independents, backed by an active financial-aid program.
Which Indianapolis private high school is best for an International Baccalaureate education? The International School of Indiana is the metro's leading IB school, offering language immersion in French, Spanish, and Mandarin and the full IB Diploma Programme in the upper school.
Do Indianapolis private high schools offer financial aid? Yes - most metro private schools, including Brebeuf, Cathedral, Bishop Chatard, Roncalli, and others, run active financial-aid programs to broaden access, so families should compare net price after aid rather than sticker tuition.
Which private high school is best for a Catholic education in Indianapolis? Brebeuf Jesuit leads for a Jesuit education, while Cathedral offers the largest Catholic college-prep experience and Bishop Chatard, Roncalli, and Guerin Catholic serve different regions of the metro with strong outcomes.
Is a private or public high school better in Indianapolis? It depends on the family: top private schools like Park Tudor and Brebeuf offer small classes, mission-driven culture, and college counseling, while strong suburban public schools like Carmel deliver large AP catalogs free of charge; the right choice depends on fit, values, and budget.
Bottom Line
For Indianapolis-area families, Park Tudor School is our Best Overall private high school - the most rigorous independent college-prep education in the metro, with near-universal four-year-college matriculation. Bishop Chatard High School is our Best Value, delivering strong Catholic college prep at an accessible tuition backed by financial aid.
If your priority is a Jesuit education, an IB and language-immersion program, or an affordable faith-based option, use the decision tree above to route yourself to Brebeuf, the International School, or Lutheran instead. Choose on mission fit, outcomes, and net cost rather than a single ranking number, and your student will be set up to succeed.
Sources
- U.S. News - Best Indiana High Schools rankings
- Niche - Best Private High Schools in the Indianapolis Area
- GreatSchools - Indiana school ratings
- Park Tudor School
- Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School
- Cathedral High School
- Bishop Chatard High School
- The International School of Indiana
- College Board - AP program data
*Private high schools in Indianapolis review - best private high schools Indianapolis, rankings, ratings, and a review of the top picks for families.*