Pulse Reviews and Analysis
Top 10 Catholic High Schools in Arizona
Curated by Chief Revenue Officer Kory White · CRO Syndicate
Top 10 Catholic High Schools in Arizona
Direct Answer
The Best Overall Catholic high school in Arizona is Brophy College Preparatory in Phoenix, a Jesuit, all-boys college-prep whose rigorous curriculum, deep AP catalog, and near-universal four-year college matriculation place it at the top statewide. The Best Value pick is Salpointe Catholic High School in Tucson, a co-ed Carmelite school that delivers strong college-prep outcomes, athletics, and a broad program at tuition below the elite Phoenix prep.
This list is built for families and students weighing where to enroll across Arizona, with a focus on academics, college outcomes, faith formation, and fit. Every pick uses real, publicly reported data from Niche, the schools, and the Diocese of Phoenix and Diocese of Tucson.
How We Ranked the Top 10
We weighted each school against the priorities Catholic families actually raise, drawing on published figures from Niche, U.S. News, Private School Review, and each school's own profile. The weighting:
- Academic performance (rigor, AP, scores) - 25%
- College and post-grad outcomes - 20%
- Value and cost - 15%
- Faith formation and service - 15%
- Teachers and resources - 15%
- Extracurriculars and fit - 10%
A school with a famous name but thin programs drops fast. The winners balance rigor, faith, and outcomes.
1. Brophy College Preparatory 🏆 BEST OVERALL
Type: Catholic (Jesuit), All-Boys | Tuition: About $19,500 | Best for: Boys seeking the most rigorous Jesuit college-prep in the state
Founded in 1928, Brophy College Preparatory in central Phoenix enrolls roughly 1,300 young men and is the flagship Jesuit school in Arizona. Brophy posts a graduation rate near 99%, one of the deepest AP catalogs in the state, and near-universal four-year college matriculation to Arizona State, the University of Arizona, Notre Dame, and selective national and Jesuit universities.
Its Christian service and summit/immersion programs anchor a strong formation tradition, and its athletics and academic teams are perennial state contenders.
Pros:
- Graduation rate near 99% with near-universal college matriculation
- One of the deepest AP catalogs in Arizona
- Strong Jesuit service and immersion programs
- Perennial athletics and academic-team contender
Cons:
- All-boys environment is not a fit for every family
- Highly competitive admission
Verdict: Brophy wins on balance, pairing the state's deepest Catholic academic programming with elite college outcomes.
2. Salpointe Catholic High School 💎 BEST VALUE
Type: Catholic (Carmelite), Co-ed | Tuition: About $14,500 | Best for: Families seeking strong co-ed Catholic college-prep in Tucson
Salpointe Catholic High School, founded in 1950 in Tucson, enrolls roughly 1,200 students and is the largest Catholic high school in southern Arizona. Salpointe posts a high graduation rate, broad AP and honors offerings, and strong four-year college matriculation.
Its athletics tradition is among the strongest in the state, and its Carmelite formation and service programs are well regarded. Tuition sits well below the elite Phoenix prep schools, making it our value pick.
Pros:
- Largest, most established Catholic school in southern Arizona
- Co-ed with broad AP and honors offerings
- Strong athletics and service tradition
- Tuition well below Phoenix prep schools
Cons:
- Large enrollment means bigger classes
- Fewer elite-university feeders than Brophy
Verdict: The best value in Arizona Catholic education, delivering broad co-ed college-prep at an accessible price.
3. Xavier College Preparatory
Type: Catholic, All-Girls | Tuition: About $17,500 | Best for: Girls seeking a rigorous all-girls Catholic college-prep in Phoenix
Xavier College Preparatory in Phoenix, founded in 1943 and historically paired with neighboring Brophy, enrolls roughly 1,200 young women. Xavier posts a graduation rate near 99%, a deep AP catalog, and near-universal four-year college matriculation. Its strong service tradition, athletics, and arts make it the premier all-girls Catholic option in the state.
Pros:
- Graduation rate near 99% with near-universal college matriculation
- Deep AP catalog
- Strong service, athletics, and arts
- Premier all-girls Catholic school in Arizona
Cons:
- All-girls environment is not for every family
- Competitive admission
Verdict: The top all-girls Catholic choice in Arizona, with rigor and outcomes to match Brophy.
4. Notre Dame Preparatory
Type: Catholic, Co-ed | Tuition: About $15,500 | Best for: Families seeking modern co-ed Catholic college-prep in the northeast Valley
Notre Dame Preparatory in Scottsdale, opened in 2002, is a co-ed Diocese of Phoenix school serving the northeast Valley. It posts a high graduation rate, broad AP offerings, and strong four-year college matriculation, with modern facilities and growing athletics and arts programs.
Pros:
- Modern facilities serving the northeast Valley
- Co-ed with broad AP offerings
- Strong and growing athletics and arts
- High graduation rate and college matriculation
Cons:
- Younger school with a shorter track record
- Smaller AP catalog than Brophy or Xavier
Verdict: The best modern co-ed Catholic option in the northeast Valley, with strong outcomes and facilities.
5. Seton Catholic Preparatory
Type: Catholic, Co-ed | Tuition: About $14,000 | Best for: Families in the East Valley seeking affordable co-ed Catholic college-prep
Seton Catholic Preparatory in Chandler serves the East Valley with a co-ed college-prep program, broad AP and honors offerings, and strong four-year college matriculation. Its athletics and service programs are strong, and tuition is among the more affordable in the Phoenix metro.
Pros:
- Affordable East Valley co-ed option
- Broad AP and honors offerings
- Strong athletics and service programs
- High graduation rate and college matriculation
Cons:
- Smaller program breadth than the largest schools
- Fewer elite-university feeders than Brophy
Verdict: A strong, affordable East Valley choice for co-ed Catholic college-prep.
6. St. Mary's Catholic High School
.jpg&w=240&h=240&fit=cover&a=attention&output=webp)
Type: Catholic, Co-ed | Tuition: About $13,000 | Best for: Families seeking the historic, affordable Catholic option in central Phoenix
St. Mary's Catholic High School, founded in 1917, is the oldest Catholic high school in Arizona and serves central Phoenix with a co-ed college-prep program. It posts a high graduation rate, AP and honors offerings, and a deep athletics tradition, with tuition among the most affordable in the metro.
Pros:
- Oldest Catholic high school in Arizona
- Affordable central-Phoenix tuition
- Deep athletics tradition
- High graduation rate and college matriculation
Cons:
- Smaller AP catalog than the elite prep schools
- Smaller enrollment limits some program breadth
Verdict: A historic, affordable central-Phoenix choice with strong tradition and solid outcomes.
7. Bourgade Catholic High School
Type: Catholic, Co-ed | Tuition: About $12,500 | Best for: Families seeking an affordable, small co-ed Catholic school in west Phoenix
Bourgade Catholic High School in west Phoenix is a small co-ed Diocese of Phoenix school offering personalized attention, AP and honors courses, and strong four-year college matriculation. Its small size supports close teacher relationships, and tuition is among the lowest in the metro.
Pros:
- Affordable west-Phoenix tuition
- Small classes with personalized attention
- AP and honors offerings
- Strong college matriculation
Cons:
- Smaller program breadth than larger schools
- Less name recognition than Brophy or Xavier
Verdict: A high-value small school for families seeking close attention in west Phoenix.
8. St. John Paul II Catholic High School
Type: Catholic, Co-ed | Tuition: About $13,500 | Best for: Families in southern Arizona seeking a growing co-ed Catholic school
St. John Paul II Catholic High School in Avondale serves the southwest Valley with a co-ed college-prep program, AP and honors offerings, and growing athletics and arts. It posts a high graduation rate and strong four-year college matriculation in a faith-centered environment.
Pros:
- Serves the growing southwest Valley
- AP and honors offerings
- Faith-centered environment
- High graduation rate and college matriculation
Cons:
- Younger school with a shorter track record
- Smaller program breadth than established schools
Verdict: A solid, faith-centered choice for the growing southwest Valley.
9. Immaculate Heart High School
Type: Catholic, Co-ed | Tuition: About $12,000 | Best for: Families seeking a small, faith-centered school in north-central Phoenix
Immaculate Heart High School in Phoenix is a small co-ed Catholic school offering a college-prep program with honors and AP courses, close teacher relationships, and a strong faith-formation focus. Tuition is among the lowest on this list.
Pros:
- Affordable north-central Phoenix tuition
- Small, close-knit community
- Honors and AP offerings
- Strong faith-formation focus
Cons:
- Very small enrollment limits program breadth
- Fewer elite-university feeders
Verdict: A close-knit, affordable option for families prioritizing faith formation and small classes.
10. St. Augustine Catholic High School
Type: Catholic, Co-ed | Tuition: About $11,500 | Best for: Tucson families seeking an affordable co-ed Catholic school
St. Augustine Catholic High School in Tucson is an affordable co-ed Diocese of Tucson school offering a college-prep program with honors and AP courses, a strong service tradition, and solid four-year college matriculation. Its low tuition and faith-centered culture make it a strong southern-Arizona value.
Pros:
- Affordable Tucson tuition near $11,500
- Honors and AP offerings
- Strong service tradition
- Solid college matriculation
Cons:
- Smaller AP catalog than Salpointe
- Smaller enrollment limits program breadth
Verdict: An affordable, faith-centered Tucson choice for families seeking value in southern Arizona.
What to Look For When Choosing a Catholic High School
- College matriculation and graduation rates - A school that graduates nearly all students and sends most to four-year colleges signals consistent outcomes.
- AP/honors depth - Look at how many advanced courses students actually complete, not just the catalog size.
- Faith formation and service - Weigh how seriously a school treats retreats, service requirements, and sacramental life if faith is a priority.
- Single-sex vs. Co-ed - Arizona has elite all-boys (Brophy), all-girls (Xavier), and many co-ed options; the right fit depends on the student.
- Tuition and aid - Net price after diocesan tuition assistance and tax-credit scholarships often differs sharply from the sticker price.
- Location - Phoenix metro and Tucson options sit far apart; weigh the daily commute.
What matters less than marketing implies: a school's age or name alone. Fit, faith culture, program access, and a supportive teacher relationship affect a student's outcome far more than reputation.
FAQ
Which Catholic high school is the best overall in Arizona? Brophy College Preparatory in Phoenix earns the top spot for its deep AP catalog, graduation rate near 99%, strong Jesuit formation, and near-universal four-year college matriculation.
What is the best value Catholic high school in Arizona? Salpointe Catholic High School in Tucson is our best value, delivering broad co-ed college-prep, strong athletics, and high college matriculation at tuition well below the Phoenix prep schools.
Which Arizona Catholic school is best for girls? Xavier College Preparatory in Phoenix is the premier all-girls Catholic school, with a deep AP catalog, graduation rate near 99%, and near-universal four-year college matriculation.
How much does Catholic high school cost in Arizona? Tuition ranges from roughly $11,500 at schools like St. Augustine to about $19,500 at Brophy, before diocesan aid and Arizona tax-credit scholarships.
Are there co-ed Catholic high schools in Arizona? Yes. Salpointe, Notre Dame Prep, Seton, St. Mary's, Bourgade, St. John Paul II, Immaculate Heart, and St. Augustine are co-ed, while Brophy is all-boys and Xavier is all-girls.
Do Arizona Catholic high schools offer financial aid? Yes. Most offer need-based aid, and Arizona's tuition tax-credit scholarship programs help many families significantly reduce net cost.
Bottom Line
For Arizona families, Brophy College Preparatory is our Best Overall Catholic high school, pairing a deep AP catalog and strong Jesuit formation with a graduation rate near 99% and near-universal college matriculation. Salpointe Catholic High School is our Best Value, delivering broad co-ed college-prep and strong athletics at accessible Tucson tuition.
If your priority is an all-girls program, a modern northeast-Valley campus, or an affordable East Valley option, route yourself to Xavier, Notre Dame Prep, or Seton instead. Choose on faith culture, program fit, and net cost after aid and tax-credit scholarships, and your student will be set up to succeed.
Sources
- Niche - Best Catholic High Schools in Arizona
- Private School Review - Arizona Catholic high schools
- Diocese of Phoenix - Catholic Schools Office
- Diocese of Tucson - Catholic Schools
- Brophy College Preparatory - official site
- Salpointe Catholic High School - official site
- Xavier College Preparatory - official site
- U.S. News - Best High Schools in Arizona
*Catholic high schools in Arizona review - best Catholic high schools Arizona, rankings, ratings, and a review of the top picks for families.*