Best Toyota Highlander Model Years (Ranked) in 2027

1. 2017 Toyota Highlander

The 2017 refresh is the best Highlander because it pairs the proven 3.5L 2GR-FKS V6 with a new eight-speed automatic, improving efficiency and smoothness over earlier third-gen models. It makes 295 horsepower and tows up to 5,000 pounds when properly equipped, while the interior quality and third-row space received meaningful upgrades. Reliability is excellent, and clean XLE or Limited AWD examples typically sell for $25,000 to $32,000.

This is the pick for families wanting the best balance of modern features, proven durability, and strong resale value. It trades away the lower price of earlier third-gen models but justifies the premium with the updated transmission and improved cabin. Compared to the 2014-2015 value pick below, the 2017 feels noticeably more current and drives better, making it worth the extra cost for most buyers.

2. 2014-2015 Toyota Highlander

These early third-gen years rank second for delivering the modern Highlander package at the best value, with the durable 3.5L V6 producing 270 horsepower and a roomier third row than the second generation. The six-speed automatic is a proven, trouble-free unit, and the styling still looks contemporary. Clean AWD examples sell for $16,000 to $22,000, undercutting later years by thousands while offering the same fundamental reliability.

This is for budget-conscious families who want the celebrated third-gen platform without paying for the 2017 refresh's upgrades. It trades away the newer eight-speed transmission and updated infotainment, but the mechanicals are essentially just as durable. Compared to the 2017 above, it feels slightly older and less refined, yet it costs significantly less, making it the better value for many.

3. 2019 Toyota Highlander

The 2019 ranks third as the final and most refined third-generation Highlander, carrying every improvement of the run plus standard Toyota Safety Sense, Apple CarPlay, and the proven 3.5L V6 with the eight-speed automatic. It delivers 295 horsepower and represents the most modern third-gen example you can buy, with the newest build date and the most driver-assistance features. Values range from $27,000 to $34,000, reflecting low-mileage examples with current-feeling technology.

This is for buyers who want the durable, well-sorted third-gen platform with the latest available tech and a recent build date. It trades away the lower price of earlier third-gen years but adds meaningful convenience and safety features. Compared to the 2017 above, the 2019 offers little mechanical difference but includes standard CarPlay and updated safety tech, making it a better choice for tech-focused families.

4. 2017-2019 Highlander Hybrid

The 2017-2019 Highlander Hybrid ranks fourth as the efficiency standout, pairing the 3.5L V6 with Toyota's hybrid system to achieve around 28-30 mpg combined while retaining V6-level power and AWD via an electric rear motor. Toyota's hybrid drivetrain is famously durable, and the electric rear motor provides genuinely useful low-speed traction in slippery conditions. Values range from $28,000 to $36,000, a premium over the gas V6 that fuel savings recoup over years of family driving.

This is for buyers who put on serious annual miles and want to minimize fuel costs without sacrificing capability or reliability. It trades away some upfront value compared to the gas V6, but the efficiency gains pay off over time. Compared to the 2019 gas model above, the hybrid costs more initially but delivers significantly better city fuel economy, making it the better pick for urban commuters.

5. 2021 Toyota Highlander

The 2021 ranks fifth as a strong early fourth-generation year, offering sharper styling, a much-improved interior, and the standard 3.5L V6 with an eight-speed automatic. By 2021, Toyota had addressed early fourth-gen infotainment complaints, and the interior materials and screen quality are a clear step up over the third generation. Values range from $32,000 to $40,000, reflecting the newer design and technology. The third row remains tight for adults, a known trait of this generation.

This is for buyers who want the newest design and tech while keeping the proven naturally aspirated V6, before Toyota moved toward turbo-four power in later years. It trades away the lower price of third-gen models but offers a more modern cabin and features. Compared to the 2017-2019 hybrid above, the 2021 gas V6 is less efficient but provides a more contemporary driving experience and interior.

6. 2016 Toyota Highlander

The 2016 ranks sixth as a strong pre-refresh third-gen year, carrying the durable 3.5L V6 with a six-speed automatic and the roomier third row of the generation. It is often priced just below a 2017, with values ranging from $20,000 to $26,000, making it a smart buy when a clean example undercuts a comparable 2017. The six-speed automatic is a proven, trouble-free unit, so you give up little by skipping the refresh.

This is for buyers who want third-gen reliability at a slightly lower price than the 2017. It trades away the updated eight-speed transmission and minor interior upgrades, but the mechanicals are just as durable. Compared to the 2021 above, the 2016 is significantly cheaper but lacks the modern tech and interior refinement. The V6 is the engine to choose for towing and resale, and a documented service history is essential for this age.

7. 2020 Highlander Hybrid

The 2020 fourth-gen Hybrid ranks seventh for its class-leading fuel economy, using a 2.5L four-cylinder hybrid system that delivers an impressive 35+ mpg combined. This is a big efficiency jump over the V6 hybrid, though power is adequate rather than strong. Values range from $34,000 to $42,000, reflecting the newer design and technology. The interior is a clear improvement over the third generation, with better materials and a larger touchscreen.

This is for buyers who prioritize maximum mpg in a roomy, reliable family SUV and can accept four-cylinder power. It trades away the effortless torque of the V6 hybrid for economy, which rarely matters for suburban family duty but is noticeable for towing or mountain driving. Compared to the 2016 gas model above, the 2020 hybrid is far more efficient and modern but costs significantly more.

8. 2011-2013 Toyota Highlander

The late second-gen years rank eighth for offering the durable 3.5L V6 in a smaller, more affordable package, with values ranging from $11,000 to $17,000. The third row is tighter and the interior dated, but the mechanicals are proven and prices are low. These trucks regularly pass 200,000 miles, making a clean high-mileage example a defensible budget buy. The V6 is the engine to favor over the four-cylinder for towing and resale.

This is for budget buyers who want Toyota reliability without third-gen money. It trades away the roomier third row and modern interior of later models, but the core drivetrain is just as durable. Compared to the 2020 hybrid above, the 2011-2013 is far cheaper but lacks efficiency and modern safety features. Watch for usual high-mileage wear items, and prioritize a documented service history over low miles.

9. 2008-2010 Toyota Highlander

The early second-gen years rank ninth as dependable and cheap options, growing the Highlander into a true three-row and introducing the 3.5L V6. Values range from $8,000 to $14,000, making them ideal for a high-mileage budget hauler. The V6 drivetrain shrugs off age, but expect dated tech and more wear at this age. For a gas V6 example with records, this is one of the cheapest reliable three-rows on the road.

This is for buyers on a very tight budget who need a reliable family SUV and can accept an older interior and fewer safety features. It trades away the refinement and room of later generations, but the mechanicals are proven. Compared to the 2011-2013 above, these years are cheaper but may have more wear and fewer features. Avoid the early second-gen Hybrid unless battery health is documented, since replacement costs can exceed the vehicle's value.

10. 2022 Toyota Highlander

The 2022 ranks tenth as one of the newest naturally aspirated 3.5L V6 Highlanders before Toyota's turbo-four shift, with the most modern fourth-gen tech and safety. It commands the highest prices here, ranging from $38,000 to $46,000, and depreciates slowly. The third row is still tight, so cross-shop a minivan if adult third-row room is a priority. This is the safe modern V6 choice for buyers nervous about later turbocharged engines.

This is for buyers who want near-new condition with the proven V6 and maximum remaining warranty, and who plan to keep the vehicle for many years. It trades away the value of older models but offers the newest design and the most advanced features. Compared to the 2008-2010 above, the 2022 is dramatically more expensive but far more refined, safe, and efficient.

How we ranked these

We ranked Highlander model years by weighting powertrain durability (35%), reliability records from NHTSA and Consumer Reports (25%), third-row usability (20%), and used-market pricing relative to value (20%). The 3.5L V6's proven longevity, transmission quality, and hybrid battery health were key differentiators, with later third-gen years scoring highest for their refined V6 and eight-speed automatic.

We deliberately ignored subjective styling preferences, brand loyalty, and dealer incentives, as these don't predict long-term ownership satisfaction. We also excluded anecdotal single-owner reports and non-verifiable forum claims, focusing instead on aggregated data and expert reviews. This ensures the ranking reflects measurable, repeatable factors that matter most for a family hauler's reliability and resale, not transient trends or personal taste.

What to look for

What actually matters is the powertrain: prioritize the 3.5L V6 (especially the 2GR-FKS from 2017+) or a documented hybrid over any four-cylinder, which struggles under load. AWD boosts resale and winter traction, and a full service history—especially timing chain, water pump, and hybrid battery checks—outweighs low mileage. The third row is tight on every generation, so verify it fits your actual passengers.

The biggest mistake is overpaying for a 2022 or later model just for the newest tech, when a 2017-2019 V6 offers nearly identical reliability for thousands less. Another error is ignoring hybrid battery health on older second-gen hybrids, where replacement costs can exceed the car's value. Always let documented maintenance, not age or mileage alone, decide between two similar examples.

Related questions

What is the most reliable Toyota Highlander engine?

The 3.5L V6, especially the 2GR-FKS version introduced around 2017, is widely considered the most durable. It avoids the oil consumption issues of earlier 2GR-FE engines and the complexity of the hybrid system, often lasting well past 200,000 miles with routine care.

Are used Highlanders from the early 2000s still worth buying?

First-generation models (2001–2007) can be good budget options if rust is minimal and the timing belt has been replaced. However, safety features and fuel economy are dated, and the third row is very tight, so they’re best for smaller families or short trips.

Which Highlander years should I avoid?

Some early third-generation models (2014–2016) had transmission hesitation and infotainment glitches, while certain 2008–2010 hybrids experienced battery degradation. Also, four-cylinder Highlanders from any year tend to feel underpowered when fully loaded.

How long does a Toyota Highlander typically last?

With proper maintenance, many Highlanders easily reach 200,000 to 250,000 miles, and some go beyond 300,000. The V6 powertrain is the key factor—hybrids can also be long-lived but may need battery replacement around the 10–15 year mark.

Is the hybrid Highlander worth the extra cost?

Yes, if you do mostly city driving, where the hybrid can deliver up to 35 mpg versus around 22 mpg for the V6. On the highway, the fuel savings shrink, so the hybrid’s higher upfront price takes longer to recoup for highway-heavy use.

What is the best year for a used Highlander under $20,000?

A well-maintained 2017 or 2018 model often falls in the $18,000–$22,000 range depending on mileage and condition. These years offer the reliable 2GR-FKS V6, updated safety tech, and a roomier third row, making them a strong value.

How does the Highlander's third row compare to competitors?

The Highlander's third row is genuinely tight on every generation, suitable only for children or short trips. Competitors like the Honda Pilot or Kia Telluride offer more adult-friendly space, so cross-shop if you regularly carry adults in the back.

FAQ

What is the best overall Toyota Highlander model year?

The 2017 Highlander is the best overall, pairing the proven 3.5L 2GR-FKS V6 with an eight-speed automatic, a roomier third row, and refinements that fixed early third-gen bugs. It offers excellent reliability, tows 5,000 lbs, and holds value well.

What is the best value Highlander model year?

The 2014-2015 third-gen Highlander is the best value, often found under $20,000 with the durable 3.5L V6 and six-speed automatic. It delivers the celebrated third-gen package—roomier third row and modern styling—for thousands less than later years.

Which Highlander years have the most reliable transmission?

The eight-speed automatic introduced with the 2017 refresh is smooth and reliable, but the earlier six-speed in 2014-2016 models is also proven and trouble-free. Both are solid, so choose based on other features and price rather than transmission concerns.

Are Highlander hybrids reliable long-term?

Yes, Toyota's hybrid system is famously durable, especially the 2017-2019 V6 hybrid. However, older second-gen hybrids (2008-2010) may need battery replacement costing thousands, so verify battery health and service records before buying an older hybrid.

What should I check when buying a used Highlander?

Inspect the AWD system for proper engagement, check for water-pump or oil leaks on V6 models, and confirm the timing chain is quiet. On hybrids, verify battery health. Also, sit in the third row yourself to ensure it fits your needs.

Is the four-cylinder Highlander worth considering?

No, the four-cylinder struggles with a full load and towing, and it doesn't offer significant fuel savings over the V6 in real-world driving. Favor the V6 or hybrid for better performance, resale, and long-term satisfaction.

How much does a used 2017 Highlander cost?

Clean XLE or Limited AWD examples typically run $25,000-$32,000, depending on mileage and condition. This price buys a decade-plus of dependable family service, making it a strong investment for most buyers.

What is the fuel economy of the Highlander Hybrid?

The 2017-2019 V6 hybrid achieves around 28-30 mpg combined, while the 2020+ four-cylinder hybrid delivers an impressive 35+ mpg combined. The V6 hybrid retains more power, while the four-cylinder hybrid prioritizes maximum efficiency.

Sources

• https://www.toyota.com/highlander
• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Highlander
• https://www.nhtsa.gov
• https://www.kbb.com
• https://www.edmunds.com
• https://www.consumerreports.org
• https://www.jdpower.com

Related on PULSE

• [More best toyota highlander model years (ranked) rankings and buying guides](/knowledge)
• [PULSE Tools and calculators](/tools)
• [Everything on PULSE RevOps](/)