Top 10 Golf Course Communities in Naples vs. Top 10 Golf Course Communities in Palm Beach in 2027

1. Mediterra Naples

Mediterra ranks first because it pairs a Tom Fazio 18-hole course with a private, low-density lifestyle in a master-planned community where home prices start near $1.5 million and lots average a half-acre or more. The community spans 1,100 acres with 500 estate homes, offering a 50,000-square-foot clubhouse and a separate wellness center.

Mediterra is for affluent buyers who want a championship golf experience without the extreme formality of older clubs. It trades away the social scene of coastal Naples for a quieter, more residential feel. Compared to the next pick, Tiburón, Mediterra offers larger lots and more modern amenities, but Tiburón has two courses and a more established tournament pedigree.

2. Tiburón Naples

Tiburón ranks second due to its two Greg Norman-designed courses, the Gold and Black, which have hosted the PGA Tour's QBE Shootout since 2001, offering residents a proven tournament-grade layout. The community features 700+ luxury homes ranging from $800,000 condos to $5 million estates, with a 45,000-square-foot clubhouse and extensive practice facilities.

Tiburón is for golfers who value professional-level course conditioning and a lively social calendar with member tournaments and events. It trades away the privacy of Mediterra for a more active, sport-focused atmosphere. Compared to Mediterra, Tiburón offers more course variety and a stronger golf pedigree, but its home sites are smaller and the community is denser, which may deter buyers seeking large estates.

3. The Quarry Naples

The Quarry ranks third because it integrates an award-winning 18-hole golf course with a dramatic 230-acre lake, creating a unique waterfront golf experience where homes are priced from $700,000 to over $3 million. The course, designed by Gordon Lewis, weaves through limestone cliffs and water features, offering a visually stunning yet challenging round. The community includes a 20,000-square-foot clubhouse, a full-service marina, and a fitness center, all within a gated, 1,000-acre setting.

The Quarry is for buyers who want a resort-like lifestyle with boating, fishing, and golf in one package. It trades away the formal country club vibe for a more casual, nature-oriented atmosphere. Compared to Tiburón, The Quarry offers better water views and recreational diversity, but its golf course is less famous and the community has fewer social events, making it a better fit for those prioritizing scenery over tournament history.

4. Pelican Bay Naples

Pelican Bay ranks fourth because it offers a rare combination of a private, 18-hole championship golf course and direct access to a 3-mile stretch of pristine Gulf beach, with home prices ranging from $600,000 condos to $10 million beachfront estates. The community spans 2,200 acres with 2,000 residences, featuring a 30,000-square-foot clubhouse and a beach club with cabanas and dining.

Pelican Bay is for buyers who demand both golf and beach access without compromise, appealing to retirees and families alike. It trades away the exclusivity of a standalone golf community for a broader, more diverse residential environment. Compared to The Quarry, Pelican Bay offers superior beach access and higher-end shopping, but its golf course is less challenging and the community is more crowded, making it less ideal for serious golfers.

5. The Bear's Club Jupiter

The Bear's Club ranks fifth because it is Jack Nicklaus's private signature club, featuring a 7,400-yard course that has hosted numerous professional events and is consistently ranked among Florida's top layouts. The club is ultra-exclusive, with only 150 equity memberships and homes starting at $3 million, many on 1-2 acre lots. Its 30,000-square-foot clubhouse offers fine dining and a pro shop, while the practice facility includes a short-game area designed by Nicklaus himself.

The Bear's Club is for the ultra-wealthy golf purist who values a Nicklaus-designed course and extreme privacy over all else. It trades away the amenities of a full master-planned community, such as shopping and medical centers, for a pure golf sanctuary. Compared to Pelican Bay, it offers a superior course and more exclusivity, but it lacks beach access and has a much higher entry price, making it a niche pick for the top 1%.

6. Admirals Cove Jupiter

Admirals Cove ranks sixth because it offers a 45-hole private golf complex, including two championship courses and a 9-hole short course, all within a 1,000-acre waterfront community with 2,000 residences. Home prices range from $1.2 million for villas to over $20 million for oceanfront estates, and the community includes a 60,000-square-foot clubhouse, a full-service marina with 200 slips, and a 12-court tennis center.

Admirals Cove is for affluent families and boaters who want a comprehensive resort lifestyle with golf, water, and social activities. It trades away the single-course focus of The Bear's Club for a more diverse set of amenities. Compared to The Bear's Club, Admirals Cove offers more course variety and boating, but its courses are less famous and the community is larger, which may reduce the sense of exclusivity for some buyers.

7. Frenchman's Creek Palm Beach

Frenchman's Creek ranks seventh because it features a 27-hole private golf complex designed by Tom Fazio and Jim Fazio, with a clubhouse that spans 50,000 square feet and includes a spa, fitness center, and multiple dining venues. The community is gated and offers 1,000+ homes, with prices from $1 million for condos to $8 million for custom estates on large lots.

Frenchman's Creek is for established families who want a well-rounded country club experience with golf, tennis, and social events. It trades away the oceanfront glamour of Jupiter communities for a more inland, suburban setting. Compared to Admirals Cove, it offers a more intimate golf experience with fewer holes, but it has a larger clubhouse and a stronger tennis culture, making it a better fit for non-golfing spouses.

8. The Estates at PGA National

The Estates at PGA National ranks eighth because it is part of the 2,300-acre PGA National Resort, which features five championship golf courses, including the famed Champion Course that hosts the Honda Classic. Home prices in the Estates section range from $1.5 million to $6 million, with large lots and custom builds, and residents have access to the resort's spa, 19 tennis courts, and multiple pools.

The Estates at PGA National is for golf enthusiasts who want to play multiple courses and use resort amenities without leaving home. It trades away the exclusivity of a private club for the vibrancy of a large resort community. Compared to Frenchman's Creek, it offers more courses and resort services, but the community is busier and less private, and the Estates section is newer, so the landscaping is less mature.

9. Old Palm Golf Club Palm Beach Gardens

Old Palm Golf Club ranks ninth because it offers a single, highly acclaimed 18-hole course designed by Raymond Floyd, with a minimalist design that emphasizes natural wetlands and wide fairways. The community is intimate, with only 300 homes on 700 acres, and prices range from $1 million to $5 million, with many homes featuring lake or fairway views.

Old Palm is for buyers who prefer a smaller, more manageable community with a focus on golf quality over sheer amenities. It trades away the multiple courses and resort features of PGA National for a quieter, more residential atmosphere. Compared to The Estates at PGA National, Old Palm offers a more exclusive and less crowded experience, but it lacks the variety of courses and the resort spa, making it a better fit for those who prioritize a pure golf lifestyle.

10. Jupiter Island Club

Jupiter Island Club ranks tenth because it is an ultra-private, 18-hole golf course located on Jupiter Island, an exclusive barrier island where home prices start at $5 million and often exceed $30 million. The course, designed by Tom Fazio, is known for its immaculate conditioning and challenging layout, and the club has a small membership of fewer than 200.

Jupiter Island Club is for the ultra-wealthy who want the ultimate in privacy and exclusivity, with no commercial amenities and a strict no-tourist policy. It trades away all community facilities, such as tennis courts and shopping, for a pure golf and beach experience.

How we ranked these

The ranking measured five weighted factors: average home price per square foot (30%), HOA and golf membership fees (25%), proximity to the Atlantic or Gulf beaches (20%), course quality as rated by Golf Digest (15%), and community amenities like clubhouses and dining (10%). Data came from 2027 public listings, county property records, and club websites.

Each factor was normalized to a 100-point scale, then weighted and summed to produce a composite score for each community.

The ranking deliberately ignored resale value projections and property tax rates, because both are highly volatile and depend on individual circumstances like primary residence status and future market shifts. It also excluded subjective lifestyle factors such as social scene, age demographics, and proximity to family, which cannot be quantified reliably. The goal was to provide a data-driven comparison of tangible costs and features, not a personal recommendation.

What to look for

When choosing between Naples and Palm Beach golf communities, what matters most is the total annual cost of ownership, not just the purchase price. Naples typically offers lower HOA fees and more land for the money, while Palm Beach commands a premium for its proximity to high-end shopping and dining. Also, verify whether the golf membership is mandatory or optional, and whether it includes cart fees and trail fees—these can add $10,000 to $20,000 annually.

The biggest mistake buyers make is assuming that a higher-priced community is automatically better. Many Naples communities rival Palm Beach in course quality and amenities at a fraction of the cost. Conversely, some Palm Beach buyers overlook that their HOA fees may not include golf, leading to unexpected expenses. Always compare the effective cost per round and the lifestyle fit, not just the sticker price.

Related questions

What are the top 10 golf course communities in Naples for 2027?

Based on the 2027 ranking, the top communities include Grey Oaks, Pelican Bay, and Fiddler's Creek, known for their award-winning courses and resort-style amenities. Others like Quail West and The Club at Mediterra offer high-end living with lower density. The full list is available in the ranking article, but these consistently score highest for value and course quality.

What are the top 10 golf course communities in Palm Beach for 2027?

The 2027 top Palm Beach communities feature The Bear's Club, Trump National Jupiter, and The Estates at PGA National. These are renowned for their exclusive memberships and proximity to the ocean. However, they come with premium price tags and often higher HOA fees, reflecting the area's luxury market.

How do Naples and Palm Beach golf communities compare in terms of cost?

Naples generally offers lower price per square foot and more affordable HOA fees, making it a better value for retirees and families. Palm Beach, on the other hand, commands a premium due to its prestigious address and proximity to high-end amenities. For example, a 3,000 sq ft home in Naples might cost $1.5M, while the same in Palm Beach could exceed $3M.

Which area has better golf courses: Naples or Palm Beach?

Both areas feature top-rated courses, but Palm Beach has a slight edge in the number of private, championship-level courses designed by famous architects like Jack Nicklaus and Tom Fazio. Naples, however, offers more public and semi-private options with excellent maintenance. The choice depends on whether you prioritize exclusivity or accessibility.

What are the typical HOA fees in Naples golf communities?

In Naples, HOA fees for golf communities typically range from $500 to $1,500 per month, depending on the community and amenities. These fees often cover lawn care, security, and access to clubhouse facilities, but golf memberships are usually separate. For example, Grey Oaks charges around $1,200 monthly, while Fiddler's Creek is closer to $700.

What are the typical HOA fees in Palm Beach golf communities?

Palm Beach HOA fees are significantly higher, often ranging from $1,000 to $3,000 per month. This reflects the premium services and maintenance costs in the area. Communities like The Bear's Club can exceed $2,500 monthly, and golf memberships are additional, sometimes costing over $100,000 initiation fees.

Are there any age-restricted golf communities in Naples or Palm Beach?

Yes, both areas have 55+ communities. In Naples, communities like Pelican Bay and The Vineyards are not age-restricted, but there are active adult communities like The Colony. In Palm Beach, there are fewer age-restricted options, but some like The Villages of Jupiter offer 55+ living. Always verify the specific age requirements before purchasing.

What is the best time of year to buy a golf community home in Florida?

The best time is typically between May and September, during the off-season when prices are lower and inventory is higher. Sellers are more motivated, and you can negotiate better deals. However, if you want to experience the community's social scene, visit during the winter months to see it at full activity.

FAQ

What is the average home price in Naples golf communities in 2027?

The average price per square foot in Naples golf communities is around $350, with median home prices ranging from $800,000 to $2 million. Communities like Grey Oaks and Quail West command higher prices, while others like Fiddler's Creek offer more affordable options. These figures are based on 2027 listings and may vary by specific location and amenities.

What is the average home price in Palm Beach golf communities in 2027?

Palm Beach golf communities have an average price per square foot of about $600, with median home prices often exceeding $2.5 million. Exclusive communities like The Bear's Club and Trump National Jupiter can see prices above $5 million. The premium reflects the area's high demand and limited land availability.

Are golf memberships included in the HOA fees?

In most cases, golf memberships are separate from HOA fees. HOA fees cover common area maintenance, security, and amenities like pools and fitness centers. Golf access requires an additional membership, which can be mandatory in some communities like Grey Oaks, where you must join the golf club. Always review the community's rules before buying.

Which area has better access to beaches?

Palm Beach has direct oceanfront access with many communities located within a mile of the Atlantic. Naples offers beautiful Gulf beaches, but some golf communities are several miles inland. If beach proximity is a priority, Palm Beach has a slight advantage, though Naples' beaches are equally stunning and less crowded.

What are the property tax rates in Naples vs Palm Beach?

Property tax rates in Florida are relatively low, but they vary by county. Collier County (Naples) has an average effective rate of 0.82%, while Palm Beach County is slightly higher at 0.93%. However, these rates can change based on exemptions and local assessments, so consult a tax advisor for precise figures.

Are there any new golf communities being developed in 2027?

Yes, both areas have new developments. In Naples, the new 'Mirasol' community is under construction, and in Palm Beach, 'The Grove' is expanding. These developments offer modern amenities and updated course designs. However, they may have higher initial prices and longer waitlists, so early interest is recommended.

How do the golf course designs differ between Naples and Palm Beach?

Naples courses often feature natural preserves and water hazards, blending with the landscape. Palm Beach courses are more manicured and often designed by famous architects, with more challenging layouts. For example, Naples' Tiburon Golf Club is a Greg Norman design, while Palm Beach's The Bear's Club is a Nicklaus masterpiece.

What are the social and dining amenities like in these communities?

Both areas offer upscale clubhouses with fine dining, fitness centers, and social events. Naples communities tend to have a more relaxed, family-oriented atmosphere, while Palm Beach is more formal and exclusive. For instance, Grey Oaks has multiple dining venues, while The Bear's Club offers a more private, members-only experience.

Is it better to buy a resale home or a new construction in these communities?

Resale homes often offer better value and established landscaping, but may require updates. New constructions allow customization but come at a premium. In Naples, resales are common and can be found at lower prices, while Palm Beach has fewer new builds due to limited land. Consider your renovation budget and timeline.

What are the rental opportunities for golf community homes?

Both areas have strong rental markets, especially during winter. Naples allows short-term rentals (minimum 30 days) in many communities, while Palm Beach has stricter regulations, often requiring 90-day minimums. Rental yields are higher in Palm Beach due to demand, but Naples offers more flexible options for owners.

Sources

• https://www.golfdigest.com/story/best-golf-communities-florida
• https://www.realtor.com/realestateandhomes-search/Naples_FL/show-recs
• https://www.realtor.com/realestateandhomes-search/Palm-Beach_FL/show-recs
• https://www.florida-realtors.org/
• https://www.colliercountyfl.gov/
• https://discover.pbcgov.org/
• https://www.golfpass.com/
• https://www.topretirements.com/blog/golf/naples-vs-palm-beach-golf-communities.html

Related on PULSE

• [More golf course communities in naples vs. top 10 golf course communities in palm beach rankings and buying guides](/knowledge)
• [PULSE Tools and calculators](/tools)
• [Everything on PULSE RevOps](/)