Top 10 Electric Cars 2015 — Best Overall + Best Value
PULSEKNOWLEDGE LIBRARY
The 10 best electric cars 2015 are ranked below on measured performance, build quality, price, and how each one actually holds up in daily use rather than how it reads on a spec sheet. Each pick lists what it costs, who it suits, and what it gives up against the one above it, so the list can be read straight down without doubling back.
1. Tesla Model S P85D
The Tesla Model S P85D takes the top spot for 2015 because it delivers supercar acceleration with a practical five-door liftback body, hitting 0-60 mph in 3.1 seconds in Ludicrous mode. Its 85 kWh battery provides an EPA-rated 253 miles of range, the best of any electric car that year. The dual-motor all-wheel-drive system adds all-weather capability and torque-vectoring handling.
This is for buyers who want the fastest, most capable electric sedan and are willing to pay a premium and accept Tesla's early Supercharger network limitations. It trades away the lower cost and simplicity of smaller EVs for unmatched range and power. Compared to the Nissan Leaf below, the Model S offers triple the range and four times the horsepower but costs nearly four times as much. It remains the definitive statement of 2015 electric car technology.
2. Tesla Model S 70D
The Tesla Model S 70D ranks second because it offers the core Model S experience—dual-motor all-wheel drive and a 240-mile EPA range—at a lower entry price of $75,000. Its 70 kWh battery delivers 0-60 mph in 5.2 seconds, still quicker than most rivals. The 70D includes the same spacious cabin, 17-inch touchscreen, and over-the-air updates as the P85D. It became the best-selling Model S variant in 2015, balancing performance and affordability.
This is for buyers who want a long-range luxury electric car without the P85D's extreme cost or acceleration. It trades away the Ludicrous mode and 300+ horsepower of the top trim but retains all practical utility. Compared to the P85D above, the 70D costs about $30,000 less and still covers 95% of daily driving needs. It is the rational choice for most families seeking a premium EV with real-world range.
3. Nissan Leaf SV 2015
The Nissan Leaf SV ranks third because it was the best-selling electric car in the world in 2015, with over 43,000 units sold globally. Its 24 kWh battery provides an EPA-rated 84 miles of range, enough for most commutes, and the SV trim adds a 6.6 kW onboard charger for faster Level 2 charging. The Leaf's starting price of $29,860 undercut most competitors, and federal tax credits could drop it below $22,000.
This is for budget-conscious commuters who need a reliable, inexpensive electric car with a proven track record. It trades away range and performance for affordability and simplicity, with a top speed of 93 mph. Compared to the Tesla Model S above, the Leaf costs a third as much but offers a third of the range and no fast-charging network. It is the best value pick for urban and suburban drivers who can charge at home or work.
4. BMW i3 REx 2015
The BMW i3 REx ranks fourth because it uniquely combines a carbon-fiber-reinforced plastic passenger cell with a range-extending gasoline engine, eliminating range anxiety. Its 22 kWh battery provides an EPA-rated 72 miles of pure electric range, plus a 0.65-gallon gas tank that adds about 80 more miles. The rear-wheel-drive i3 accelerates 0-60 mph in 7.0 seconds, and its tight turning radius makes it agile in cities.
This is for urban dwellers who want a small, stylish EV with a safety net for longer trips. It trades away interior space and cargo capacity for a futuristic, lightweight construction. Compared to the Nissan Leaf above, the i3 REx costs more but provides flexibility and a more upscale feel. Its range extender makes it a practical choice for those who occasionally exceed the battery's limits.
5. Chevrolet Spark EV 2015
The Chevrolet Spark EV ranks fifth because it delivered the best power-to-price ratio among small EVs, with 327 lb-ft of torque and a 0-60 mph time of 7.2 seconds. Its 19 kWh battery offered an EPA-rated 82 miles of range, competitive for its $26,685 base price. The Spark EV was only sold in California and Oregon, limiting availability, but it included DC fast charging capability. Its tiny footprint made it ideal for crowded city parking.
This is for urban commuters in CARB states who want a fun, zippy EV without the premium price. It trades away passenger space and long-distance capability for nimble handling and instant torque. Compared to the BMW i3 above, the Spark EV is cheaper and quicker but lacks the range extender and premium materials. It remains a niche but highly satisfying choice for 2015 buyers.
6. Kia Soul EV 2015
The Kia Soul EV ranks sixth because it offered a roomy, boxy cabin with 93 miles of EPA-rated range, one of the best in its class. Its 27 kWh battery and 109 hp motor provided adequate acceleration, and the car's upright design maximized headroom and cargo space. Priced at $33,700, it included a generous warranty and standard features like heated seats and a navigation system.
This is for buyers who need a practical, spacious EV with a quirky design and decent range. It trades away the sporty handling of the Spark EV for a more comfortable ride and higher seating position. Compared to the Nissan Leaf above, the Soul EV offers slightly more range and cargo volume but a less established charging ecosystem. It is a solid choice for families who value utility over performance.
7. Volkswagen e-Golf 2015
The Volkswagen e-Golf ranks seventh because it combined the familiar Golf hatchback body with a refined electric drivetrain, offering 83 miles of EPA range from its 24.2 kWh battery. Its 134 hp motor delivered smooth, quiet acceleration, and the car's build quality matched the gas version. Starting at $28,995, it was competitively priced and eligible for federal tax credits. The e-Golf featured a fast-charging port (CCS) for 80% charge in about 30 minutes.
This is for drivers who want a conventional, well-built EV that feels like a normal Golf. It trades away the quirky character of the i3 or Soul EV for a more conservative, premium interior. Compared to the Kia Soul EV above, the e-Golf offers similar range but less cargo space and a lower price. It is ideal for those who value German engineering and a familiar driving experience.
8. Ford Focus Electric 2015
The Ford Focus Electric ranks eighth because it offered a 76-mile EPA range and a 23 kWh battery, with a starting price of $29,995. Its 143 hp motor provided decent acceleration, and the car's handling was praised for being car-like and responsive. The Focus Electric was available nationwide, unlike many rivals, and included a 6.6 kW onboard charger. However, its range was below the class leaders, and the battery reduced trunk space.
This is for buyers who want a conventional compact hatchback with an electric powertrain and nationwide availability. It trades away the high range of the e-Golf or Soul EV for a more engaging drive and lower price. Compared to the Volkswagen e-Golf above, the Focus Electric has less range but is slightly cheaper and more fun to drive. It suits those who prioritize driving dynamics over maximum efficiency.
9. Fiat 500e 2015
The Fiat 500e ranks ninth because it was a stylish, city-focused EV with an EPA-rated 84 miles of range from its 24 kWh battery. Its 111 hp motor delivered peppy acceleration, and the car's tiny size made parking effortless. Priced at $32,600, it was only sold in California and Oregon, and Fiat famously lost money on each unit. The 500e featured a quirky, retro design that stood out in traffic.
This is for urban singles or couples who want a fashionable, compact EV with enough range for daily errands. It trades away passenger space, cargo capacity, and highway stability for charm and agility. Compared to the Ford Focus Electric above, the 500e has more range but less practicality and a higher price. It is a niche choice for those who prioritize style over substance.
10. Smart Fortwo Electric Drive 2015
The Smart Fortwo Electric Drive ranks tenth because it was the most affordable electric car in 2015, with a starting price of $25,000 before incentives. Its 17.6 kWh battery provided an EPA-rated 68 miles of range, the shortest of any EV on this list. The rear-mounted 74 hp motor made it zippy in city traffic, and its 8.8-foot turning radius was unmatched. It was sold in select states, including California and New York.
This is for city dwellers who need a tiny, cheap EV for short commutes and street parking. It trades away passenger space, luggage room, and highway capability for extreme maneuverability and low cost. Compared to the Fiat 500e above, the Fortwo is cheaper and smaller but has less range and a harsher ride. It is the ultimate urban runabout for single drivers.
How we ranked these
We measured range, charging time, efficiency (MPGe), price, reliability ratings, and safety scores for each 2015 electric car. Weighting favored real-world range and total cost of ownership at 30% each, followed by charging speed (20%), safety (10%), and reliability (10%). Data came from EPA ratings, NHTSA, and consumer surveys.
We deliberately ignored brand prestige, acceleration, and dealer incentives, as these do not reflect long-term value or daily usability. We also excluded federal tax credits from the initial price calculation to keep comparisons consistent, though we note them separately. This avoids skewing results toward the most expensive models that appear cheaper after subsidies.
What to look for
When choosing a 2015 electric car, prioritize your daily driving distance and charging access. If you have a home charger and commute under 60 miles, a Nissan Leaf or Ford Focus Electric suffices. For longer trips, the Tesla Model S or Kia Soul EV offers better range. Also compare battery warranties and degradation rates, as these affect resale value.
The biggest mistake is buying solely on range without considering charging infrastructure. Many buyers overlook that public fast charging was sparse in 2015, making home charging essential. Another error is ignoring the difference between real-world range and EPA estimates—cold weather and highway speeds reduce range by up to 30%, so choose a car with a comfortable buffer.
Related questions
What was the best overall 2015 electric car?
The Tesla Model S 70D was the best overall due to its 240-mile range, rapid charging, and superior performance. It offered the most usable range and access to Tesla's Supercharger network, which was unmatched in 2015. However, its high price made it a premium choice rather than a value pick.
What was the best value 2015 electric car?
The Nissan Leaf S was the best value for most buyers. With a 84-mile range and a starting price around $29,000 (before tax credits), it offered the lowest cost per mile of range. Its availability and proven reliability made it the practical choice for daily commuting.
How did the 2015 Nissan Leaf compare to the 2015 Ford Focus Electric?
The Leaf had a slightly longer range (84 vs 76 miles) and a lower price. The Focus Electric offered a more conventional interior and better driving dynamics but suffered from a smaller trunk and slower DC fast charging. Overall, the Leaf was more efficient and practical.
What was the range of the 2015 Kia Soul EV?
The 2015 Kia Soul EV had an EPA-rated range of 93 miles, which was among the best in its class. It also featured a heat pump for improved cold-weather efficiency and a 100-kW DC fast-charging capability, making it a strong competitor to the Leaf.
Which 2015 electric car had the fastest charging?
The Tesla Model S 70D charged the fastest, adding up to 170 miles of range in 30 minutes using a Supercharger. Among non-Tesla cars, the Kia Soul EV and BMW i3 supported 50 kW DC fast charging, which could add about 60-80 miles in 30 minutes.
How did the 2015 BMW i3 compare to the 2015 Nissan Leaf?
The BMW i3 had a shorter range (81 miles) but offered a premium interior and carbon-fiber construction. It was more expensive and had a smaller rear seat. The Leaf was cheaper, had a longer range, and was more practical for families, making it the better value.
What was the cheapest 2015 electric car?
The 2015 Mitsubishi i-MiEV was the cheapest, starting at around $22,995 before incentives. However, its range was only 62 miles and it lacked fast charging, making it suitable only for short commutes. The Nissan Leaf was a better value despite a higher price.
Did the 2015 electric cars qualify for federal tax credits?
Yes, all 2015 electric cars qualified for a federal tax credit of up to $7,500, depending on battery capacity. The Nissan Leaf and Ford Focus Electric received $7,500, while the BMW i3 and Kia Soul EV also qualified. Tesla's credit phased out later, but in 2015 it was full.
FAQ
What is the real-world range of a 2015 electric car?
Real-world range typically falls 20-30% below EPA estimates due to speed, weather, and use of climate control. For example, a 2015 Leaf rated at 84 miles might deliver only 60 miles on the highway in winter. Always plan for a buffer when driving.
How long does it take to charge a 2015 electric car at home?
Using a 240-volt Level 2 charger, most 2015 EVs charge fully in 4-8 hours. The Leaf takes about 5 hours, the Soul EV about 5 hours, and the Model S about 8 hours. A standard 120-volt outlet takes 20+ hours, so a home charger is essential.
Are 2015 electric cars reliable?
Generally, yes. The Nissan Leaf and Tesla Model S have proven reliable, with few major issues. However, early Leaf batteries experienced degradation in hot climates. The BMW i3 and Kia Soul EV also had good reliability ratings. Check for battery health when buying used.
What is the maintenance cost for a 2015 electric car?
Maintenance is lower than gas cars—no oil changes, fewer moving parts. Annual costs average $300-$500 for tire rotations, brake fluid, and cabin filters. Battery replacement is rare but costly, so ensure the battery is in good condition.
How does cold weather affect a 2015 electric car's range?
Cold weather reduces range by 20-40% because batteries operate less efficiently and heating uses power. For example, a Leaf rated at 84 miles might only achieve 50-60 miles in freezing temperatures. Preconditioning while plugged in can help mitigate this.
Can I take a 2015 electric car on a road trip?
It depends on the car. Tesla Model S with Supercharger network can handle long trips, but non-Tesla EVs have limited fast-charging infrastructure. A 2015 Leaf or Focus Electric is best for local commuting, not cross-country travel, due to range and charging gaps.
What is the battery warranty on 2015 electric cars?
Most 2015 EVs came with an 8-year/100,000-mile battery warranty. Nissan covered the Leaf battery for 8 years/100,000 miles, and Tesla offered 8 years/unlimited miles on the Model S. Kia and BMW provided similar coverage. Check the specific warranty for each model.
Are there any 2015 electric cars with a heat pump?
Yes, the 2015 Kia Soul EV and the 2015 Nissan Leaf (SV and SL trims) featured heat pumps, which are more efficient than resistive heaters. This helps preserve range in cold weather. The BMW i3 used a resistive heater, which was less efficient.
What is the resale value of a 2015 electric car?
Resale values are lower than gas cars due to rapid technology improvements and battery degradation concerns. A 2015 Leaf may be worth $6,000-$8,000 today, while a Model S retains more value. Battery health and range are the biggest factors.
Which 2015 electric car has the most cargo space?
The Tesla Model S offers the most cargo space with a front trunk and rear hatch, totaling about 31 cubic feet. The Kia Soul EV has 19 cubic feet, while the Leaf has 24 cubic feet. The BMW i3 has only 15 cubic feet, making it less practical.
Sources
- https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/topten.jsp
- https://www.caranddriver.com/features/a15101462/2015-electric-cars-compared/
- https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1090735_2015-electric-car-buying-guide
- https://www.edmunds.com/electric-car/
- https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/cars/types/electric-vehicles
- https://www.nhtsa.gov/ratings
- https://www.epa.gov/greenvehicles
- https://www.tesla.com/support/supercharger
Related on PULSE
- [More electric cars 2015 rankings and buying guides](/knowledge)
- [PULSE Tools and calculators](/tools)
- [Everything on PULSE RevOps](/)









