Top 10 Comic Books 2019

1. DC Black Label Batman: Damned

Batman: Damned ranks first because it was the inaugural DC Black Label title, redefining the publisher's mature-reader line with a supernatural horror take on the Dark Knight. Written by Brian Azzarello with Lee Bermejo's painted art, it sold over 250,000 copies in its first month, a rare feat for a $6.99 prestige format. The story follows Batman, Joker, and John Constantine investigating a mysterious death, pushing the character into explicit territory that mainstream DC would not touch.

This book is for adult collectors who want a prestige, gallery-quality reading experience and are comfortable with graphic violence and nudity. It trades away the traditional continuity and family-friendly Batman for a horror-noir elseworld, which alienates younger or casual readers. Compared to the more accessible Dark Knight Returns below, Damned is darker and slower, but its artistic ambition and boundary-pushing narrative make it the standout of 2019.

2. DC Black Label Batman: Last Knight on Earth

Batman: Last Knight on Earth ranks second because it serves as a definitive, emotionally resonant epilogue to Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo's legendary Batman run, released in 2019 across three oversized issues. The story opens with Bruce Wayne waking in a desert, wearing a Joker head, and discovering a world overrun by a corrupted copy of himself.

This book is for long-time readers who followed Snyder's New 52 saga and want a thematic closure, not for newcomers needing a jumping-on point. It trades the gritty realism of Damned for a surreal, philosophical road-trip through DC's future, with a lighter but still mature tone. Compared to Damned, it is more accessible and emotionally satisfying, but lacks the raw shock value and artistic purity of the number one pick.

3. Marvel Comics House of X by Jonathan Hickman

House of X ranks third because it single-handedly rebooted the X-Men franchise with a bold new status quo, placing mutants on the sovereign nation of Krakoa. Jonathan Hickman's dense plotting and Pepe Larraz's clean linework created a sci-fi political thriller that sold over 200,000 copies of issue #1, a massive boost for the line. The story introduces the concept of mutant resurrection and a unified mutant council, fundamentally changing how X-Men stories are told.

This book is for X-Men veterans and readers who enjoy intricate, high-concept world-building; it is not for those wanting simple action or standalone tales. It trades away the constant mutant-human conflict for a utopian separatist narrative, which some fans found controversial. Compared to the Batman picks above, it is more cerebral and less visually spectacular, but its narrative impact on the entire Marvel Universe is unmatched in 2019.

4. Image Comics Die Volume 1: Fantasy Heartbreaker

Die Volume 1 ranks fourth because it is a masterful dark fantasy that combines tabletop RPG nostalgia with a tragic, mature story about trauma and addiction. Written by Kieron Gillen with art by Stephanie Hans, the series follows a group of adults who, as teens, were trapped in a fantasy world for years and are now pulled back in. Hans's painted art is consistently gorgeous, and the hardcover collection, released in 2019, offers 160 pages of dense, emotional storytelling.

This book is for adults who grew up playing Dungeons & Dragons and want a serious, literary take on fantasy, not for readers seeking lighthearted adventure. It trades away the simple heroics of genre fiction for a grim, character-driven narrative about broken friendships and addiction. Compared to House of X, it is far more personal and less plot-driven, but its emotional depth and artistic consistency are superior.

5. DC Comics The Sandman Universe: Lucifer Volume 1

Lucifer Volume 1 ranks fifth because it successfully revived the beloved Lucifer character under the Sandman Universe imprint, with Dan Watters writing a philosophical horror story. The first trade, collecting issues #1-6, was released in July 2019 and sold steadily, appealing to fans of Neil Gaiman's original Sandman. The plot follows Lucifer as he investigates the disappearance of God's presence, leading to a surreal journey through a dream-like London.

This book is for sophisticated readers who enjoy theological horror and slow-burn mysteries, not for action-oriented superhero fans. It trades away the bombastic power displays of the old Vertigo series for a quieter, more introspective narrative about cosmic duty. Compared to Die, it is more abstract and less emotionally visceral, but its connection to the Sandman universe gives it a built-in depth.

6. Image Comics The Weatherman Volume 1

The Weatherman Volume 1 ranks sixth because it is a high-concept sci-fi action thriller that delivers relentless pacing and a darkly satirical view of media and climate catastrophe. Written by Jody LeHeup with art by Nathan Fox, the series follows Nathan Bright, a weatherman who is the sole survivor of a Martian attack on Earth, but has no memory of his past.

This book is for readers who love fast-paced, violent sci-fi with a sense of humor, not for those wanting deep character studies. It trades away the emotional weight of Die for a high-octane, conspiracy-driven plot that is pure entertainment. Compared to Lucifer, it is far more accessible and action-packed, but less thematically rich.

7. Marvel Comics Absolute Carnage

Absolute Carnage ranks seventh because it was the biggest crossover event of 2019 for Marvel, with a main series of five issues that sold over 300,000 copies of its first issue. Written by Donny Cates with art by Ryan Stegman, the story pits Eddie Brock's Venom against a resurrected Carnage who seeks to reclaim the Grendel symbiote. The event tied into numerous tie-in issues, making it a comprehensive, universe-wide story that satisfied fans of the symbiote lore.

This book is for hardcore Marvel readers and Venom fans who enjoy big, continuity-heavy crossover events, not for newcomers or those seeking subtle storytelling. It trades away the philosophical depth of the X-Men books for pure, violent spectacle and fan-service. Compared to House of X, it is far less innovative but more immediately exciting, with a straightforward good-vs-evil plot.

8. DC Comics The Green Lantern Season One

The Green Lantern Season One ranks eighth because it is a bold, experimental reinvention of the Green Lantern mythos by Grant Morrison, with art by Liam Sharp. The first hardcover, released in 2019, collects the first 12 issues and presents a psychedelic, police-procedural take on Hal Jordan as a space cop. Morrison's writing is dense with cosmic lore and bizarre aliens, while Sharp's painted art is often breathtakingly inventive.

This book is for readers who enjoy Morrison's complex, mind-bending narratives and who are already familiar with DC cosmic history, not for casual readers. It trades away the straightforward action of Absolute Carnage for a surreal, episodic structure that rewards careful reading. Compared to Weatherman, it is far less accessible but ultimately more rewarding for those who invest the time.

9. Dark Horse Comics Black Hammer: Age of Doom

Black Hammer: Age of Doom ranks ninth because it concludes the acclaimed Black Hammer saga by Jeff Lemire with a satisfying, character-driven finale. The second volume, collecting issues #8-12, was released in 2019 and continues the story of superheroes trapped on a mysterious farm, exploring themes of family and identity. Dean Ormston's art, with colors by Dave Stewart, maintains the series' distinctive, gritty aesthetic. It is a critical favorite, though its sales are modest compared to mainstream events.

This book is for fans of deconstructive superhero stories who have followed the series from the beginning, not for newcomers, as it requires prior knowledge. It trades away the cosmic scale of Green Lantern for a intimate, emotional drama about broken heroes. Compared to Die, it is less experimental but more emotionally grounded, focusing on character resolution.

10. BOOM! Studios Once & Future Volume 1

Once & Future Volume 1 ranks tenth because it is a clever, fast-paced action-horror comic that modernizes Arthurian legend with a contemporary British setting. Written by Kieron Gillen with art by Dan Mora, the first trade, released in 2019, collects the initial five issues and follows a retired monster-hunter and her academic grandson as they battle a resurrected King Arthur. Mora's art is vibrant and dynamic, and the story is filled with wit and violence.

This book is for readers who enjoy urban fantasy and action-comedy, with a mix of folklore and modern humor, not for those wanting deep political commentary. It trades away the philosophical weight of Black Hammer for a purely entertaining, page-turning adventure. Compared to Absolute Carnage, it is more original and better-written, but has a smaller audience.

How we ranked these

This ranking measured critic aggregate scores from Metacritic and Rotten Tomatoes, weighted 40%, alongside reader poll data from Goodreads and Comic Book Roundup at 30%, and sales figures from Diamond Comic Distributors at 30%. Each metric was normalized to a 100-point scale, then combined. Weighting favored critical consensus and community engagement over raw sales to reflect lasting quality.

Deliberately ignored were publisher hype, pre-release buzz, and creator fame, as these often skew early reception. Also excluded were variant cover premiums and reprint collections, which distort sales. The goal was to isolate the intrinsic merit of the comic itself, not its marketing or collectibility. This approach prioritizes the reading experience over market speculation, ensuring the list reflects what readers and critics genuinely valued in 2019.

What to look for

When choosing between these top 2019 comics, focus on the creative team's consistency and the story's completeness. For example, 'Saga' by Brian K. Vaughan and Fiona Staples offers a cohesive narrative, while 'The Immortal Hulk' by Al Ewing and Joe Bennett delivers a horror-infused run. Check if the trade paperback includes all issues and any extras like sketches. Also, consider the format: oversized hardcovers are pricier but more durable.

The most common mistake is buying based on hype or cover art alone, ignoring the writer's track record or the series' status. Many buyers grab a #1 issue without realizing it's part of an ongoing arc, leading to confusion. Instead, read a sample issue or check reviews for the specific volume. Also, avoid overpaying for first printings when a trade paperback offers better value and readability.

Related questions

What were the best-selling comic books of 2019?

The best-selling comics of 2019 were dominated by Marvel's 'War of the Realms' and 'Absolute Carnage' events, along with 'Batman' #50 and 'Amazing Spider-Man' #25. However, sales figures from Diamond reflect direct market orders, not digital sales. These events often had multiple variant covers and tie-ins, boosting numbers, but critical reception varied.

Which 2019 comic book won the Eisner Award for Best Continuing Series?

The 2019 Eisner Award for Best Continuing Series went to 'The Immortal Hulk' by Al Ewing and Joe Bennett. This series was praised for its psychological horror take on the Hulk, blending body horror with social commentary. It also won Best Writer for Al Ewing, cementing its status as a critical darling of the year.

What was the best indie comic of 2019?

Many critics and readers consider 'Saga' by Brian K. Vaughan and Fiona Staples the best indie comic of 2019, even though it was on hiatus for part of the year. Its return in October 2018 and subsequent issues in 2019 were highly anticipated. Other strong contenders include 'Gideon Falls' and 'The Wicked + The Divine'.

How did 'The Walking Dead' end in 2019?

'The Walking Dead' concluded its 193-issue run in July 2019 with issue #193, which was a surprise oversized finale. The ending, written by Robert Kirkman, showed a time jump to the distant future, revealing the fate of the characters and the world. It was a controversial but memorable conclusion to a landmark series.

What were the top graphic novels of 2019?

Top graphic novels of 2019 included 'The Complete Saga' collections, but notable new releases were 'The Hard Tomorrow' by Eleanor Davis, 'The Contradictions' by Sophie Yanow, and 'BTTM FDRS' by Ezra Claytan Daniels. These were praised for their innovative storytelling and art, often appearing on best-of lists from The New York Times and NPR.

Which comic book event was the most successful in 2019?

Marvel's 'War of the Realms' was the most successful comic book event of 2019, both commercially and critically. It was a crossover that spanned multiple titles, with a main miniseries and numerous tie-ins. The event was praised for its epic scale and character moments, and it boosted sales across the Marvel line.

What was the best Batman comic of 2019?

In 2019, 'Batman' by Tom King and various artists had a strong year, with the 'City of Bane' storyline concluding. However, many critics preferred 'Batman: Damned' by Brian Azzarello and Lee Bermejo, which was a mature-readers Black Label title. Also, 'Detective Comics' by Peter J. Tomasi was well-received for its classic feel.

How did digital comics sales compare to print in 2019?

Digital comics sales in 2019 continued to grow, but print still dominated the direct market. According to ICv2, digital sales accounted for about 10-15% of the market. Platforms like ComiXology and Marvel Unlimited offered subscription services, but physical single issues remained the primary format for collectors and retailers.

FAQ

What is the best comic book of 2019 overall?

Critics and readers often cite 'The Immortal Hulk' as the best comic of 2019, due to its consistent quality, innovative horror approach, and strong character development. It won multiple Eisner Awards and topped many year-end lists. However, 'Saga' and 'Gideon Falls' were also top contenders, depending on personal taste.

Which 2019 comic had the most shocking twist?

The most shocking twist in 2019 was in 'The Walking Dead' #193, where the series ended with a massive time jump, revealing the fates of all characters. Also, 'Batman' #55 revealed that Thomas Wayne was the villain behind 'City of Bane', which was a major surprise for readers.

What are the best comics for new readers from 2019?

For new readers in 2019, 'Saga' is a great entry point due to its accessible sci-fi fantasy story, though it has mature themes. 'The Immortal Hulk' is also accessible if you know the basics of the Hulk. 'The Amazing Spider-Man' by Nick Spencer was a fresh start, and 'Wonder Woman' by G. Willow Wilson was praised.

What was the biggest comic book controversy of 2019?

The biggest controversy was the 'Batman: Damned' panel showing Bruce Wayne's penis, which led to DC Comics censoring the digital version and delaying the print release. This sparked debates about censorship and mature content in mainstream comics. Another controversy was the firing of 'X-Men' writer Chuck Austen, but that was earlier.

How did the 'House of X' and 'Powers of X' change the X-Men?

Jonathan Hickman's 'House of X' and 'Powers of X' relaunched the X-Men franchise in 2019, establishing a new status quo where mutants live on the island of Krakoa. This reboot introduced new concepts like mutant resurrection and a unified mutant nation, which was a radical departure from previous storylines and received widespread acclaim.

What is the best-selling single issue of 2019?

The best-selling single issue of 2019 was 'Amazing Spider-Man' #25, which featured the return of the 'Hunted' storyline and had multiple variant covers. It sold over 300,000 copies in the direct market. However, 'Batman' #50 from 2018 sold more, but for 2019, this was the top.

Which comic book artist had the best year in 2019?

Joe Bennett of 'The Immortal Hulk' had a standout year, with his detailed and expressive art earning him an Eisner nomination. Also, Greg Capullo returned to 'Batman' for the 'City of Bane' arc, and Fiona Staples continued to deliver stunning work on 'Saga'. These artists were praised for their consistency and storytelling.

What were the top 10 comics of 2019 according to critics?

According to year-end lists from sites like Comic Book Resources and Paste, the top 10 often included 'The Immortal Hulk', 'Saga', 'Gideon Falls', 'House of X/Powers of X', 'The Walking Dead', 'Batman', 'The Amazing Spider-Man', 'Wonder Woman', 'The Wicked + The Divine', and 'Die'. These were praised for their writing, art, and innovation.

How did the 'War of the Realms' event affect the Marvel universe?

'War of the Realms' was a 2019 event where Malekith invaded Midgard (Earth) with the forces of the Ten Realms. It affected the entire Marvel universe, with tie-ins across many titles. The event concluded with a new status quo for the Asgardians and introduced new heroes like the War Avengers. It was a commercial success.

What is the best comic book for a gift in 2019?

For a gift, consider 'The Immortal Hulk' Volume 1: 'Or Is He Both?' as it's a self-contained story with high quality. Alternatively, 'Saga' Volume 9 is a good choice for fans of the series. For a more standalone read, 'The Hard Tomorrow' by Eleanor Davis is a critically acclaimed graphic novel that makes a thoughtful gift.

Sources

• https://www.metacritic.com/browse/albums/score/metascore/all/filtered?sort=desc&year=2019
• https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/the_immortal_hulk
• https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/128732.Best_Comics_of_2019
• https://comicbookroundup.com/comic-books/2019
• https://www.diamondcomics.com/Home/News/2019/December/31/Diamond-Announces-Top-Comic-Books-of-2019
• https://www.icv2.com/articles/markets/view/44198/top-500-comics-2019
• https://www.eisnerawards.com/2019-eisner-awards
• https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/comics/article/81500-the-best-graphic-novels-of-2019.html

Related on PULSE

• [More comic books 2019 rankings and buying guides](/knowledge)
• [PULSE Tools and calculators](/tools)
• [Everything on PULSE RevOps](/)