Top 10 Private High Schools in Orlando in 2027

1. Lake Highland Preparatory School

Lake Highland Preparatory School ranks first for its combination of scale, resources, and outcomes: roughly 2,000 students, tuition near $30,000 per year, an extensive AP catalog, and matriculation to selective national universities. Its college counseling is among the most thorough in Central Florida, and its athletics and arts programs compete nationally.

It suits families who want the deepest program catalog and are willing to pay premium tuition for a large nonsectarian independent. The trade-off is cost and a bigger enrollment than smaller privates. Compared with The First Academy below, Lake Highland offers more resources and a secular mission, but less faith integration and a higher price.

2. The First Academy

The First Academy ranks second as Orlando's strongest Christian college-prep option, enrolling about 1,300 students at roughly $20,000 per year. It pairs a broad AP program and small classes with highly competitive athletics and strong college matriculation, all within a nondenominational Christian mission.

It fits families who want rigorous academics and competitive sports inside a faith-based environment. The trade-off is that the Christian mission narrows its appeal and tuition remains premium. Against Bishop Moore below, it costs more and carries a nondenominational rather than Catholic identity, but offers larger athletics and resources.

3. Bishop Moore Catholic High School

Bishop Moore Catholic High School ranks third and takes Best Value: about 1,100 students, tuition near $13,500 per year, a solid AP catalog, and a near-universal four-year college matriculation rate. Parish-affiliated tuition assistance widens access well beyond what elite independents offer at nearly double the price.

It suits Catholic families and value-focused families wanting strong college prep plus service programs and community. The trade-off is fewer resources than the elite independents and a Catholic mission not every family shares. Against Trinity Preparatory School below, it gives up some rigor and selectivity but costs roughly half as much.

4. Trinity Preparatory School

Trinity Preparatory School ranks fourth for academic rigor: roughly 900 students in grades 6-12, tuition near $28,000 per year, a deep AP catalog, and exceptional matriculation to highly selective national universities. Its college counseling and debate and arts programs are among the region's best, with small classes and close faculty ties.

It suits families in Seminole County prioritizing selective-college admission and a values-based Episcopal-affiliated community. The trade-off is high tuition and competitive admission. Against Montverde Academy below, Trinity Prep is smaller and more traditionally academic, while Montverde offers boarding and elite athletics.

5. Montverde Academy

Montverde Academy ranks fifth as the standout for boarding and elite athletics: about 1,500 students, day tuition near $25,000 per year, AP and international curriculum options, and globally strong college matriculation. Its basketball program is nationally famous, and its international community draws students worldwide.

It suits international, boarding, and elite-athletics families, including those west of Orlando. The trade-off is a boarding-oriented culture and a location outside the metro core. Against Windermere Preparatory School below, Montverde leans athletics and global boarding, while Windermere centers on the full IB diploma.

6. Windermere Preparatory School

Windermere Preparatory School ranks sixth as the top independent IB choice: about 1,400 students, tuition near $27,000 per year, and a full International Baccalaureate diploma as an IB World School. It offers day and boarding options, small classes, and matriculation across U.S. and international universities.

It suits families committed to the globally recognized IB pathway and a modern, internationally minded campus. The trade-off is premium tuition and a demanding IB workload. Against Orangewood Christian School below, Windermere Prep is larger, secular, and IB-focused, while Orangewood offers Christian college prep at lower cost.

7. Orangewood Christian School

Orangewood Christian School ranks seventh for small-school Christian college prep: about 700 students in Maitland, tuition near $16,000 per year, a solid AP catalog, and strong matriculation. Its smaller scale supports close student-faculty relationships and individualized college counseling.

It suits families wanting a clear Christian mission, personal attention, and moderate tuition. The trade-off is a smaller program catalog and fewer athletics and arts offerings than larger privates. Against Lake Mary Preparatory School below, Orangewood is smaller and faith-based, while Lake Mary Prep offers boarding and IB-track options in Seminole County.

8. Lake Mary Preparatory School

Lake Mary Preparatory School ranks eighth for globally oriented Seminole County families: about 800 students, tuition near $24,000 per year, day and boarding options, and college-prep plus IB-track coursework. Its small scale supports individualized attention, and its international boarding community adds global perspective.

It suits international and IB-leaning families wanting a tight community with robust arts and athletics. The trade-off is higher tuition and smaller size than the largest metro independents. Against The Geneva School below, Lake Mary Prep is larger and internationally focused, while Geneva offers a classical Christian curriculum at lower cost.

9. The Geneva School

The Geneva School ranks ninth for its distinctive classical Christian model: about 500 students in Casselberry, tuition near $15,000 per year, and a trivium-based curriculum built on great-books study, rigorous writing, rhetoric, and Latin. Matriculation is strong for its size, with small classes and a tight intellectual community.

It suits families specifically seeking classical, faith-based education rather than a conventional AP-driven model. The trade-offs are a narrower program range and smaller athletics. Against Central Florida Christian Academy below, Geneva is smaller and classically focused, while CFCA offers broader AP and honors courses at lower tuition.

10. Central Florida Christian Academy

Central Florida Christian Academy ranks tenth as the budget-friendly Christian option: about 700 students in west Orlando, tuition near $12,000 per year, AP and honors courses, small classes, and solid college matriculation. Its faith-integrated curriculum and individualized attention widen access for cost-conscious families.

It suits families wanting an affordable Christian college-prep environment on Orlando's west side. The trade-offs are fewer resources and a smaller athletics and arts catalog than larger privates. Against The Geneva School above, CFCA is larger and more conventional in curriculum but less distinctive in mission and rigor.

How we ranked these

We weighted each Orlando private high school on six published factors: academic performance including AP and IB participation plus college matriculation (25%), college and post-graduate outcomes (20%), value relative to tuition (15%), teachers, class size, and campus resources (15%), environment and faith or mission fit (15%), and extracurriculars including arts and athletics (10%). Figures came from U.S. News, Niche, school profiles, and accreditation bodies such as SAIS, Cognia, and NCEA.

We deliberately ignored marketing language, campus age or newness of buildings, single headline rankings, and prestige reputation divorced from outcomes. We also excluded athletic recruitment pipelines and boarding-only metrics that do not apply to day families, since those inflate perceived strength without reflecting the typical Orlando student's classroom experience. Weighting favored measurable outcomes over impressions, so a high price with thin results dropped rather than rose.

What to look for

Between these schools, the real differentiators are mission fit, program architecture, and net cost after aid, not the ranking order. A student who thrives in a 500-student classical Christian setting may struggle at a 2,000-student independent, and an IB diploma workload suits some learners far better than a broad AP catalog. Ask where recent graduates actually enrolled, not where the brochure says they were accepted.

The mistake most buyers make is choosing on prestige or a single ranking number while ignoring net cost after tuition assistance and the day-to-day reality of class size, counseling access, and commute. Families also overlook faith or curricular fit until mid-year transfers become necessary. Visit twice, sit in on classes, and ask current parents about counseling caseloads and course availability before committing.

Related questions

How does Lake Highland Preparatory School compare to Trinity Preparatory School?

Lake Highland is larger, with about 2,000 students, deeper athletics, and a broad AP catalog in downtown Orlando. Trinity Prep is smaller at roughly 900 students in Winter Park, with exceptional selective-college matriculation, strong debate, and close faculty relationships. Choose Lake Highland for scale and resources; choose Trinity Prep for a tighter, intensely academic Seminole County community.

Is Bishop Moore Catholic High School worth it compared to the elite independents?

For many families, yes. Bishop Moore delivers strong college matriculation, a solid AP catalog, and a full extracurricular slate at roughly $13,500 versus $28,000 to $30,000 at the top independents. It offers fewer resources and a Catholic mission, but parish tuition assistance can lower net cost further, making it Orlando's clearest value play.

Which Orlando private school is best for the International Baccalaureate diploma?

Windermere Preparatory School is an IB World School offering the full diploma alongside college-prep coursework, with a strong international community and global matriculation. Lake Mary Prep also offers IB-track options in Seminole County. Both are demanding, so confirm your student wants the IB workload and internal assessment structure before committing.

How much does private high school cost in Orlando in 2027?

Tuition spans roughly $12,000 at schools like Central Florida Christian Academy to about $30,000 at Lake Highland Preparatory School. Catholic and Christian schools generally sit between $12,000 and $20,000, while independents run $24,000 to $30,000. Always ask about tuition assistance, parish discounts, and multi-child reductions, which can meaningfully cut net cost.

Which Orlando private high school has the strongest athletics program?

Montverde Academy is nationally known for elite athletics, especially basketball, and draws students globally through its boarding program. Lake Highland Prep and The First Academy also field highly competitive teams across multiple sports. If athletics is the priority, weigh recruitment-level competition against whether your student will actually make the roster and get playing time.

What is the difference between classical Christian and standard Christian college prep?

The Geneva School uses a classical model built on the trivium, great-books study, Latin, and rhetoric, producing a distinctive humanities-heavy education. The First Academy, Orangewood Christian, and Central Florida Christian Academy use a more conventional AP-driven Christian college-prep approach. Classical suits families wanting a specific pedagogical tradition; standard Christian prep offers broader course catalogs and athletics.

Do Orlando private high schools offer boarding options?

Yes. Montverde Academy and Lake Mary Preparatory School both operate day and boarding programs with strong international communities. Windermere Prep also offers day and boarding options. Boarding expands access for families relocating or traveling, but confirm supervision, weekend programming, and college counseling support for boarding students specifically before enrolling.

How important is college counseling when comparing these schools?

Very. Counseling caseloads vary widely: a school with 2,000 students may assign hundreds per counselor, while a 500-student school can offer near-individualized guidance. Ask how many seniors each counselor handles, how early planning starts, and what recent matriculation lists actually show. Strong counseling often matters more to outcomes than a marginally higher AP count.

FAQ

Which private high school is the best overall in Orlando?

Lake Highland Preparatory School earns the top spot for its deep AP catalog, thorough college counseling, strong matriculation to selective universities, and nationally competitive athletics and arts. Its downtown Orlando campus and roughly 2,000-student enrollment support resources few regional peers match, though tuition near $30,000 and a large student body are real tradeoffs.

What is the best value private high school in Orlando?

Bishop Moore Catholic High School is the value pick, delivering strong college matriculation, a faith-integrated curriculum, and a full extracurricular slate at roughly $13,500, well below the elite independents. Parish-affiliated tuition assistance can lower net cost further. The tradeoff is fewer resources than Lake Highland or Trinity Prep and a Catholic mission not every family shares.

Are there strong faith-based private high schools in Orlando?

Yes. Bishop Moore is Catholic, The First Academy and Orangewood Christian are nondenominational Christian, The Geneva School is classical Christian, and Central Florida Christian Academy offers affordable Christian college prep. Each integrates faith differently, so attend a chapel or religion class and review the statement of faith before deciding whether the mission genuinely fits your family.

Which Orlando private school is best for elite athletics?

Montverde Academy is nationally known for elite athletics, especially basketball, with a global boarding population. Lake Highland Prep and The First Academy also field highly competitive teams. If your student is a serious athlete, ask about roster depth, playing time, recruiting support, and whether athletics would crowd out academic course selection.

How large are class sizes at Orlando private high schools?

Most schools on this list advertise small classes, typically 15 to 20 students in upper-school sections, with smaller seminars at independents like Trinity Prep and The Geneva School. Larger schools offer more electives but can have bigger introductory courses. Ask for actual section averages by department, not a school-wide marketing figure.

Do these schools require entrance exams or interviews?

Most selective independents, including Lake Highland, Trinity Prep, and Windermere Prep, require an application, standardized testing such as the SSAT or ISEE, teacher recommendations, and a family interview. Catholic and Christian schools often have more accessible admission but still review records and conduct placement testing. Apply early, since competitive schools fill seats months ahead.

What AP or IB courses are available at Orlando private high schools?

Lake Highland, Trinity Prep, and The First Academy offer broad AP catalogs across STEM, humanities, and arts. Windermere Prep offers the full IB diploma, and Lake Mary Prep offers IB-track options. The Geneva School emphasizes classical coursework over AP. Compare actual course offerings in your student's intended subjects rather than total counts.

How do I compare college matriculation data between these schools?

Ask each school for a multi-year matriculation list showing where graduates enrolled, not just acceptances, and what share went to selective universities. Niche and U.S. News publish summaries, but school-provided lists are more current. Be skeptical of lists that name only a handful of prestigious placements without showing the full graduating class distribution.

Is it worth paying $30,000 for Lake Highland over a $13,500 Catholic school?

It depends on fit and finances. Lake Highland offers deeper resources, broader course offerings, and stronger national athletics. Bishop Moore offers strong outcomes at less than half the cost. If your student will use the extra programs and aid is limited, the premium may be justified; otherwise, net cost differences can outweigh marginal outcome gains.

When should we start the application process for 2027 admission?

Begin roughly 12 to 18 months before enrollment. Testing, recommendations, essays, and interviews take months, and competitive Orlando schools fill seats early. Attend fall open houses the year prior, request financial aid forms alongside the application, and confirm deadlines individually, since Catholic, Christian, and independent schools often run different timelines.

Sources

• https://www.niche.com/k12/lake-highland-preparatory-school-orlando-fl/
• https://thefirstacademy.org/about/contact/
• https://www.niche.com/k12/bishop-moore-catholic-high-school-orlando-fl/
• https://www.niche.com/k12/trinity-preparatory-school-winter-park-fl/
• https://www.niche.com/k12/montverde-academy-montverde-fl/
• https://www.boardingschoolreview.com/windermere-preparatory-school-profile
• https://www.privateschoolreview.com/orangewood-christian-school-profile
• https://www.studyusa.com/en/schools/p/fl070/lake-mary-preparatory-school
• https://www.privateschoolreview.com/central-florida-christian-academy-profile
• https://www.usnews.com/education/k12/florida

Related on PULSE

• [More private high schools in orlando rankings and buying guides](/knowledge)
• [PULSE Tools and calculators](/tools)
• [Everything on PULSE RevOps](/)