Top 10 Movies of the 2000s

The two films that define the decade, side by side

Every ranking of 2000s cinema eventually narrows to the same two titles, and they represent opposite theories of what a great film should do. *The Return of the King* is the culmination argument: a 201-minute conclusion that only works because two prior films built 350 minutes of investment ahead of it. Peter Jackson shot all three installments back-to-back in New Zealand between 1999 and 2000, then spent years in post-production releasing one per December — 2001, 2002, 2003. That structure is unrepeatable at studio scale, and it is why the third film's payoff lands the way it does. When Aragorn tells the hobbits "My friends, you bow to no one," the moment costs the audience nothing to understand because nine hours of setup already did the work.

*The Dark Knight* is the compression argument. Nolan had 152 minutes and no trilogy-length runway — *Batman Begins* (2005) established the character but not the moral stakes — so he front-loads escalation. The film opens on a bank robbery that eliminates its own participants, and by the ferry sequence it has staged three separate impossible-choice scenarios in under two and a half hours. Where Jackson earns emotion through accumulation, Nolan earns it through pressure.

The measurable gap between them shows up in awards versus repeat viewing. *Return of the King* went 11-for-11 at the 76th Academy Awards, tying *Ben-Hur* (1959) and *Titanic* (1997) for the all-time record, and it remains the only fantasy film to win Best Picture. *The Dark Knight* won two Oscars — Best Supporting Actor for Heath Ledger and Best Sound Editing — and its Best Picture snub is widely credited with pushing the Academy to expand the category from five nominees to as many as ten starting with the 2009 ceremony. That snub is itself a data point: the film's cultural pressure changed the institution that overlooked it.

Access differs too. Both currently sit on Max in the U.S. with rent-or-buy options on Prime Video and Apple TV, but *Return of the King* exists in two materially different cuts: the 201-minute theatrical version and the 263-minute extended edition. Choosing between them is a real decision, not a formality — the extended cut adds the Mouth of Sauron and the Saruman confrontation, roughly an extra hour. *The Dark Knight* has one cut, and portions were shot in IMAX 70mm, so the aspect ratio expands and contracts depending on the presentation. On a home screen that variation is a curiosity; in a theater it is the whole point.

Choosing between them by what you actually want tonight

The wrong way to pick is by aggregate score, because both films sit in the same critical tier and the numbers will not separate them. The right way is by three practical constraints: how much time you have, whether you are watching alone or with people, and whether you have seen the prerequisites.

Time is the hardest gate. *Return of the King* theatrical is 201 minutes — you need a full evening, and if you have not watched *The Fellowship of the Ring* (178 min) and *The Two Towers* (179 min), the honest commitment is roughly 9.3 hours of theatrical cuts or 11.4 hours extended. That is a weekend project, not a Tuesday. *The Dark Knight* at 152 minutes fits a single sitting, and while *Batman Begins* helps, the film is legible without it because Nolan reintroduces every relationship it depends on.

Company matters second. *Return of the King* rewards a group that has already made the trilogy commitment together — the payoffs are collective. *The Dark Knight* works better as a first-time watch for a mixed group because its tension is self-contained; nobody needs briefing.

Third, consider whether you want catharsis or unease. Jackson's film resolves. Nolan's does not — it ends on Batman taking the blame for Harvey Dent's murders, a lie the sequel spends its entire runtime unwinding. If the evening calls for a clean emotional landing, that is a real strike against *The Dark Knight*.

If neither fits, the decade offers well-defined alternates by mood. For a critic's-consensus drama, *There Will Be Blood* (2007, 158 min) and *No Country for Old Men* (2007, 122 min) — released within months of each other and competing at the same ceremony — are the standard picks. For all-ages viewing, *Spirited Away* (2001, 125 min) and *WALL-E* (2008, 98 min) are both Best Animated Feature winners. For a puzzle, *Memento* (2000, 113 min). For international crime, *City of God* (2002, 130 min).

The numbers behind each pick

Runtime, awards, and release year are the three verifiable figures worth building a decision on, so here is the full field with each one stated plainly.

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003) — Peter Jackson, 201 min theatrical / 263 min extended, PG-13. Won all 11 Oscars it was nominated for, including Best Picture, Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best Original Song. Howard Shore scored all three films and won Best Original Score for *Fellowship* and *Return of the King*.

The Dark Knight (2008) — Christopher Nolan, 152 min, PG-13. Two Oscars from eight nominations. Heath Ledger died in January 2008, months before release; his Best Supporting Actor win was the second posthumous acting Oscar in Academy history after Peter Finch for *Network* (1976).

There Will Be Blood (2007) — Paul Thomas Anderson, 158 min, R. Two Oscars: Best Actor for Daniel Day-Lewis and Best Cinematography for Robert Elswit. Loosely adapted from Upton Sinclair's 1927 novel *Oil!*. Jonny Greenwood of Radiohead wrote the score, which was ruled ineligible for Best Original Score because it incorporated his prior concert work. The opening reel runs roughly 15 minutes with no dialogue.

No Country for Old Men (2007) — Joel and Ethan Coen, 122 min, R. Four Oscars: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best Supporting Actor for Javier Bardem. Adapted from Cormac McCarthy's 2005 novel. The film uses no traditional musical score, which is why its silences land as hard as they do.

WALL-E (2008) — Andrew Stanton, 98 min, G. Won Best Animated Feature. Roughly the first 40 minutes contain almost no dialogue. Sound designer Ben Burtt, who created R2-D2's voice for *Star Wars*, built WALL-E's vocalizations.

Gladiator (2000) — Ridley Scott, 155 min, R. Five Oscars including Best Picture and Best Actor for Russell Crowe. Oliver Reed died during production and his remaining scenes were completed with early digital face replacement, an expensive technical solve that a modern production would handle differently.

City of God (2002) — Fernando Meirelles and Kátia Lund, 130 min, R. Four Oscar nominations — Director, Adapted Screenplay, Cinematography, Editing — in 2004, a year after its U.S. release, and notably not in the Foreign Language category. Cast largely with non-professional actors from Rio favelas.

Spirited Away (2001) — Hayao Miyazaki, 125 min, PG. Won Best Animated Feature and the Golden Bear at the Berlin International Film Festival. It held the Japanese box-office revenue record for roughly two decades before *Demon Slayer: Mugen Train* passed it. Hand-drawn at Studio Ghibli with limited digital assistance.

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004) — Michel Gondry, 108 min, R. Won Best Original Screenplay for Charlie Kaufman, Gondry, and Pierre Bismuth. Kate Winslet was nominated for Best Actress. Gondry built most memory-collapse effects in-camera with forced perspective and practical lighting rather than post-production compositing.

Memento (2000) — Christopher Nolan, 113 min, R. Two nominations, Original Screenplay and Film Editing, no wins. Adapted from "Memento Mori," a short story by Nolan's brother Jonathan. Two interleaved timelines — color running backward, black-and-white running forward — meet at the midpoint.

The pattern in those numbers: 2007 was the decade's densest year for prestige drama, 2008 for genre elevation, and the two animated winners bookend the decade's argument that animation is a medium rather than a children's category.

Sequencing a watch and what it actually costs

Treat this as a queue rather than a single choice, because the films have dependencies and the order changes the experience.

Start with the standalone titles. *The Dark Knight*, *No Country for Old Men*, *Spirited Away*, *WALL-E*, and *Memento* require no prior viewing. Five films, roughly 610 minutes total — about ten hours, or five weeknights. If you finish those and want more, you have already sampled crime, animation, thriller, and blockbuster from the decade.

Then decide on the trilogy. This is the expensive commitment. Theatrical cuts total 558 minutes; extended cuts total 726. A workable schedule is one film per weekend across three weekends, watching extended editions only if you already know you like the material — the added hour in *Return of the King* is largely payoff and denouement, which rewards existing investment and tests newcomers.

Handle the 2007 pair deliberately. *There Will Be Blood* and *No Country for Old Men* competed head-to-head, and watching them within a few days of each other is genuinely illuminating: both are about violence in the American West, both end abruptly, both refuse conventional resolution. Watching them back-to-back in one night is a mistake, though — 280 minutes of unrelieved bleakness is more than most viewers want.

Slot the subtitled and animated entries where attention is highest. *City of God* and *Spirited Away* both demand active viewing — one for subtitles, one for dream logic that punishes half-attention. Do not put them on as background.

Cost is worth stating plainly. Streaming coverage rotates, so any specific service claim ages fast; the durable statement is that these titles are consistently available for digital rental in the $3–$4 range and purchase in the $10–$20 range on major storefronts, with several rotating through Max, Disney+, and Paramount+ depending on the month. Buying the *Lord of the Rings* extended trilogy outright is generally the better value than three separate rentals if you expect to rewatch. For the animated pair, physical media remains relevant — Ghibli releases in particular have historically moved on and off streaming.

What separated the winners from the rest of the decade

Three forces produced this specific list, and understanding them explains why other well-liked 2000s films did not make it.

Genre elevation. Before 2008, superhero films were reviewed as superhero films. *The Dark Knight*'s eight nominations and the Best Picture expansion that followed changed the review frame permanently. The same shift happened in animation: the Best Animated Feature category was only created for the 2001 ceremony, and *Spirited Away* winning it in 2003 — a hand-drawn Japanese film beating American studio competition — established immediately that the category was not a domestic consolation prize.

Practical craft over digital shortcuts. The films that aged best leaned physical. Nolan shot IMAX sequences in-camera and flipped a real truck on a Chicago street. Gondry built memory dissolves with forced perspective and lighting. Jackson used bigatures — large-scale miniatures — alongside CGI, which is why Minas Tirith still reads as solid. The 2000s films that leaned hardest on early-2000s digital effects are precisely the ones that look dated now, and none of them are on this list.

Ambition that risked failure. *WALL-E* spends 40 minutes with a near-silent robot before introducing a human. *Memento* runs half its story backward. *There Will Be Blood* opens on 15 wordless minutes of a man in a hole. *City of God* cast non-actors from the neighborhoods it depicts. Each of those was a real production risk that a note-driven process would have sanded off.

What mattered less than it appeared to at the time: opening-weekend box-office revenue. *There Will Be Blood* and *City of God* were never wide commercial hits, and both now sit permanently on best-of-decade lists, while several of the decade's biggest earners have largely dropped out of the conversation. Commercial performance predicted sequels; it did not predict durability.

FAQ

What is the single best movie of the 2000s?

*The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King* (2003) has the strongest objective case. It won all 11 Oscars it was nominated for — tying the all-time record — and remains the only fantasy film ever to take Best Picture. If you want the decade's most complete achievement rather than its most rewatchable one, it is the answer.

Which 2000s movie holds up best on repeat viewing?

*The Dark Knight* (2008), largely because of Heath Ledger's Joker and the density of its plotting — the Harvey Dent arc and the interrogation scene reveal more each time. *Memento* (2000) is a close second for a different reason: its backward structure is designed to be reassembled across viewings.

How much time does watching the full list take?

Roughly 1,400 minutes for the ten theatrical cuts, or about 23 hours. Dropping to the five standalone films — *The Dark Knight*, *No Country for Old Men*, *Spirited Away*, *WALL-E*, *Memento* — cuts it to about ten hours with no prerequisite viewing.

Which of these won the most Academy Awards?

*Return of the King* with 11, then *Gladiator* with five, *No Country for Old Men* with four, and *There Will Be Blood* with two. *The Dark Knight*, *WALL-E*, *Spirited Away*, and *Eternal Sunshine* each won at least one; *Memento* and *City of God* were nominated without winning.

Are the subtitled entries worth the friction?

Yes, and both are among the decade's best. *City of God* (2002) earned four Oscar nominations including Director and Adapted Screenplay — unusual for a non-English film outside the foreign-language category — and *Spirited Away* (2001) won Best Animated Feature outright. Ghibli's English dub is well-regarded if subtitles are a hard blocker.

Where do these films stream?

Availability rotates constantly, so treat any specific claim as perishable. Historically these titles have cycled through Max, Disney+, and Paramount+, and all are reliably available for digital rental or purchase on Prime Video and Apple TV. Check a current availability tracker rather than trusting a list.

Is the extended edition of Return of the King worth the extra hour?

Only on a rewatch. The 263-minute cut adds the Mouth of Sauron and a Saruman confrontation, plus extended denouement. First-time viewers should take the 201-minute theatrical version — the extended edition rewards people who already care about the characters.

Why did The Dark Knight not get a Best Picture nomination?

It received eight nominations in 2009 but not Best Picture, which was capped at five nominees. The backlash contributed to the Academy expanding the category to as many as ten films the following year.

Which 2000s films work best for kids?

*WALL-E* (G, 98 min) is the safest choice. *Spirited Away* (PG, 125 min) is extraordinary but contains genuinely unsettling imagery — the parents-into-pigs sequence and No-Face — that lands hard on younger viewers.

What is the shortest strong entry on this list?

*WALL-E* at 98 minutes, followed by *Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind* at 108 and *Memento* at 113. All three fit comfortably in a single evening with no prerequisites.

Do I need to see Batman Begins first?

It helps but is not required. *The Dark Knight* reestablishes Bruce Wayne's relationships with Alfred, Gordon, and Lucius Fox early enough that a newcomer can follow everything. Rachel Dawes is recast between films, which occasionally confuses returning viewers more than new ones.

Sources

• Academy Awards — Official Oscars Ceremonies Database
• IMDb — Top Rated Movies
• Rotten Tomatoes
• Metacritic — Movies
• RogerEbert.com — Great Movies
• The Criterion Collection
• British Film Institute — Sight and Sound
• Letterboxd

Related on PULSE

• [Top 10 Sci-Fi Movies of All Time](/knowledge/mv0001)
• [Top 10 Fantasy Movies of All Time](/knowledge/mv0012)
• [Top 10 Musical Movies of All Time](/knowledge/mv0014)
• [Top 10 Movies on Netflix 2027](/knowledge/mv0015)
• [Top 10 Movies on Max 2027](/knowledge/mv0016)