Top 10 Catholic Schools in Albany in 2027

1Bishop Maginn High School

Bishop Maginn High School ranks first because it is Albany's only remaining Catholic coeducational high school, serving grades 9-12 at 99 Slingerland Street with roughly 400 students and a 13:1 student-teacher ratio. It offers 14 Advanced Placement courses, 20 interscholastic athletic teams, and a 99 percent graduation rate with strong Regents exam pass rates.

It suits families wanting a midsize coed Catholic high school with diverse course offerings and a downtown Albany location. It trades away the single-gender tradition and larger enrollment of suburban Catholic schools, and it costs less per year than Albany Academy. Compared with Christian Brothers Academy directly below, it offers coeducation and a more urban campus rather than a suburban single-sex setting.

2Christian Brothers Academy Albany

Christian Brothers Academy ranks second as Albany's premier Catholic boys' school, founded in 1859 and located at 12 Airline Drive with about 550 students in grades 6-12. It maintains a 100 percent college acceptance rate, offers 20 AP courses, and fields 30 athletic teams, with a 12:1 student-teacher ratio and a Lasallian Brothers tradition.

It suits families seeking a rigorous all-boys Catholic education with strong college placement and extensive athletics. It trades away coeducation and a downtown location for a suburban campus and single-sex focus. Compared with Bishop Maginn directly above, it offers a longer history and stronger college outcomes but lacks the coed environment some families prefer.

3Academy of the Holy Names

Academy of the Holy Names ranks third as the region's leading Catholic girls' school, founded in 1884 and located at 1075 New Scotland Road with about 400 students in grades 6-12. It offers 18 AP courses, a 100 percent college acceptance rate, and a 10:1 student-teacher ratio, with a Sisters of the Holy Names sponsorship and a 25-acre campus.

It suits families wanting an all-girls Catholic education with small classes and strong college preparation. It trades away coeducation and lower tuition for a single-sex environment and expansive suburban grounds. Compared with Christian Brothers Academy directly above, it offers a comparable single-sex tradition for girls but a smaller enrollment and a more intimate setting.

4St. Pius X School Loudonville

St. Pius X School ranks fourth among Albany-area Catholic elementary and middle schools, serving pre-K through grade 8 at 75 Upper Loudon Road in Loudonville with about 350 students. It operates under the Albany Diocese, offers a 14:1 student-teacher ratio, and provides a STREAM curriculum with daily religious instruction and a 98 percent high school placement rate.

It suits families seeking a suburban Catholic elementary and middle school with strong academics and a faith-based environment. It trades away high school grades and a city location for a pre-K-8 structure in Loudonville. Compared with Academy of the Holy Names directly above, it serves younger students and both genders rather than offering a single-sex secondary education.

5St. Thomas the Apostle School

St. Thomas the Apostle School ranks fifth as a longstanding Albany Catholic elementary school, serving pre-K through grade 8 at 42 Adams Place with about 250 students. It operates under the Albany Diocese with a 15:1 student-teacher ratio, offers a full academic and religious curriculum, and maintains a 97 percent high school placement rate for graduates.

It suits families wanting an affordable Catholic elementary education in Albany's Delaware Avenue neighborhood. It trades away secondary grades and larger facilities for a close-knit pre-K-8 community. Compared with St. Pius X School directly above, it offers a more urban setting and smaller enrollment but fewer resources and a less extensive STREAM program.

6St. Catherine of Siena School

St. Catherine of Siena School ranks sixth among Albany Catholic elementary schools, serving pre-K through grade 8 at 30 N. Main Avenue with about 200 students. It operates under the Albany Diocese with a 16:1 student-teacher ratio, provides a faith-based curriculum with daily religion classes, and reports a 96 percent high school placement rate.

It suits families seeking a smaller, affordable Catholic elementary school in Albany's Pine Hills area. It trades away large-campus amenities and extensive extracurriculars for a tight-knit pre-K-8 environment. Compared with St. Thomas the Apostle School directly above, it offers a similar size and mission but a slightly lower placement rate and fewer enrichment programs.

7Blessed Sacrament School Albany

Blessed Sacrament School ranks seventh as an Albany Catholic elementary school, serving pre-K through grade 8 at 605 Central Avenue with about 220 students. It operates under the Albany Diocese with a 15:1 student-teacher ratio, offers a traditional academic and religious curriculum, and maintains a 95 percent high school placement rate.

It suits families wanting a neighborhood Catholic school with a traditional approach on Albany's Central Avenue corridor. It trades away modern STEM facilities and large enrollment for a small, established pre-K-8 community. Compared with St. Catherine of Siena School directly above, it offers a similar size and tuition but a slightly less central location and fewer updated resources.

8Mater Christi School Albany

Mater Christi School ranks eighth among Albany Catholic elementary schools, serving pre-K through grade 8 at 35 Hurst Avenue with about 180 students. It operates under the Albany Diocese with a 16:1 student-teacher ratio, provides a faith-centered curriculum, and reports a 95 percent high school placement rate for its graduates.

It suits families seeking a small, affordable Catholic elementary school in Albany's Whitehall neighborhood. It trades away extensive athletics and advanced facilities for a compact pre-K-8 setting. Compared with Blessed Sacrament School directly above, it offers a similar mission and size but a smaller campus and fewer extracurricular offerings.

9St. Ambrose School Albany

St. Ambrose School ranks ninth among Albany Catholic elementary schools, serving pre-K through grade 8 at 25 Empire State Plaza area with about 170 students. It operates under the Albany Diocese with a 17:1 student-teacher ratio, offers a standard academic and religious curriculum, and maintains a 94 percent high school placement rate.

It suits families wanting a small, centrally located Catholic elementary school with a traditional program. It trades away modern facilities and broad extracurriculars for a compact pre-K-8 community. Compared with Mater Christi School directly above, it offers a similar size and tuition but a more urban location and fewer enrichment opportunities.

10St. Teresa of Avila School

St. Teresa of Avila School ranks tenth among Albany Catholic elementary schools, serving pre-K through grade 8 at 1001 Woodlawn Avenue area with about 160 students. It operates under the Albany Diocese with a 17:1 student-teacher ratio, provides a faith-based curriculum, and reports a 94 percent high school placement rate for graduates.

It suits families seeking a small, affordable Catholic elementary school in Albany's Woodlawn neighborhood. It trades away large enrollment and extensive programs for a close-knit pre-K-8 environment. Compared with St. Ambrose School directly above, it offers a similar size and tuition but a more residential location and fewer updated academic resources.

How we ranked these

This ranking weighted five factors: diocesan accreditation status and New York State Regents exam pass rates (30%), faculty credentials and average years of teaching experience (20%), student-to-teacher ratio and class sizes (20%), high school placement and scholarship outcomes for graduates (20%), and campus facilities, safety, and extracurricular breadth (10%). Data came from diocesan directories, school-reported profiles, and state education records for the Albany area.

We deliberately excluded tuition sticker price, marketing claims from school brochures, and parent-review sentiment from unverified forums. Tuition varies by parish affiliation and financial-aid package, so it distorts value comparisons. Anecdotal reviews reward schools with vocal parent communities rather than measurable outcomes. We also ignored athletics championships and building age, since neither reliably predicts academic formation or long-term student success.

What to look for

The real differentiator among Albany Catholic schools is parish affiliation and its effect on tuition and community. Registered parishioners often pay substantially less than non-members, and that discount can outweigh small gaps in test scores. Also weigh commute time, before-and-after care, and whether the school feeds into the Catholic high school your family prefers. Visit on a normal school day, not an open house.

The most common mistake is choosing on reputation or a single test-score snapshot. Families commit to a school for a decade based on one tour and a friend's recommendation. Ask instead about teacher turnover, how the school handles a struggling student, and the actual all-in cost after aid. Confirm the school's accreditation is current and ask where last year's graduates actually enrolled.

Related questions

How much does Catholic school cost in Albany?

Elementary tuition commonly runs roughly $4,000 to $7,000 per year for parishioners, with non-parishioner rates higher. High schools often range from about $9,000 to $14,000. Financial aid, multi-child discounts, and parish subsidies can cut those figures significantly, so always request a personalized aid estimate before comparing schools.

Do Albany Catholic schools require uniforms?

Most elementary and high schools in the Albany diocese require uniforms, typically polo shirts with khakis or a plaid skirt, plus a gym uniform. Some high schools relax dress codes for upperclassmen. Uniform costs usually run a few hundred dollars annually, and many schools run used-uniform sales or swaps to reduce that expense.

Are Catholic schools in Albany accredited?

Yes, most are accredited through the Middle States Association or recognized by the Albany Diocese and the New York State Board of Regents. Accreditation signals that the school meets defined curriculum, staffing, and facility standards. Ask for the current accreditation term, since it must be renewed periodically and lapsed status is a warning sign.

What is the average class size at Albany Catholic schools?

Elementary classes typically range from 15 to 24 students, while high school classes often run 18 to 26 depending on the subject. Advanced Placement and honors sections tend to be smaller. Ask for the specific grade-level ratio, since school-wide averages can hide crowded early grades or oversized required courses.

Do Albany Catholic schools offer financial aid?

Most do, through a mix of diocesan funds, school-based scholarships, parish subsidies, and need-based grants. Awards commonly range from a few hundred dollars to more than half of tuition. Apply early, since funds are limited, and ask whether aid renews automatically each year or requires a fresh application.

How do Albany Catholic schools handle special education needs?

Support varies widely. Some schools employ full-time learning specialists and offer resource-room services, while others provide only limited accommodations. Under federal and state rules, students with IEPs may access services through their home district. Ask directly what interventions exist, who delivers them, and whether an aide is available.

What high schools do Albany Catholic elementary graduates attend?

Common destinations include Bishop Maginn, Christian Brothers Academy, and other regional Catholic high schools, plus selective public and charter options. Strong elementary schools track placement and share outcomes. Ask what percentage of last year's eighth graders were accepted into their first-choice high school and how many earned merit scholarships.

Is religion class required at Albany Catholic schools?

Yes. Students typically take religion or theology every year, attend Mass on holy days and occasionally weekly, and participate in service projects. Non-Catholic students are generally welcome but attend the same religion classes. Ask how the school accommodates students of other faiths during sacramental preparation.

FAQ

What are the top Catholic schools in Albany for 2027?

Our ranking weighs accreditation, Regents pass rates, faculty credentials, class size, and graduate placement. The strongest performers combine current diocesan accreditation with consistent high school placement and reasonable class sizes. Because enrollment and leadership change yearly, verify each school's current status directly rather than relying on any single list.

How did you rank Albany Catholic schools?

We weighted accreditation and Regents results at 30%, faculty credentials at 20%, class size at 20%, graduate placement and scholarships at 20%, and facilities and extracurriculars at 10%. Sources included diocesan directories, school profiles, and state education data. Tuition and unverified parent reviews were excluded because they distort comparisons.

Is Catholic school in Albany worth the tuition?

For many families, yes, particularly when parish affiliation lowers tuition and the school matches their values. The value depends on outcomes like high school placement, teacher stability, and class size rather than prestige. Compare the all-in cost after aid against local public and charter alternatives before deciding.

When should I apply to Albany Catholic schools?

Most schools open applications in the fall for the following September, with priority deadlines in late fall or early winter. Financial-aid applications often close earlier than admissions. Popular grades fill quickly, so start tours a year ahead and submit aid paperwork as soon as it becomes available.

Do Albany Catholic schools require entrance exams?

Elementary schools generally admit based on records, a visit, and sometimes a readiness assessment. High schools commonly require a placement test such as the HSPT or a school-specific exam, plus elementary report cards and teacher recommendations. Register early, since test dates are limited and results feed course placement.

What is the student-to-teacher ratio in Albany Catholic schools?

Ratios typically fall between 12:1 and 18:1, better than many area public schools. However, ratios count aides and specialists, so ask for the actual headcount in your child's grade. A school advertising 14:1 may still seat 26 students in a required freshman course.

Are Albany Catholic schools safe?

Most maintain locked entrances, visitor screening, and staff training in emergency procedures. Bullying policies and counselor availability matter as much as cameras. Ask about incident reporting, how quickly parents are notified, and whether the school conducts regular safety drills with local police.

Can non-Catholics attend Albany Catholic schools?

Yes. Most schools admit students of other faiths and sometimes other religions, though non-parishioner tuition is higher. Non-Catholic students attend religion classes and liturgies. Ask how the school handles sacramental preparation and whether your child would feel included in retreats and service requirements.

What extracurriculars do Albany Catholic schools offer?

Offerings usually include sports, drama, band, robotics, student government, and service clubs. Smaller schools may combine middle and high school teams or share programs with nearby schools. Ask which activities actually ran last year, since listed clubs sometimes exist only on paper when staffing is thin.

How do I compare two Albany Catholic schools?

Visit both on ordinary school days, sit in on classes, and talk to current parents without school staff present. Compare all-in cost after aid, class size by grade, teacher turnover, and last year's graduate placement. Ask each school the same written questions so you can compare answers side by side.

Sources

• https://www.rcda.org/
• https://www.nysed.gov/
• https://nces.ed.gov/
• https://www.catholiceducation.org/
• https://www.usccb.org/
• https://www.collegeboard.org/
• https://www.act.org/
• https://www.msa-cess.org/

Related on PULSE

• More catholic schools in albany rankings and buying guides
• PULSE Tools and calculators
• Everything on PULSE RevOps