Best Toyota Yaris Model Years (Ranked) in 2027

1. 2019-2020 Mazda-built Yaris

The 2019–2020 Yaris ranks first because it is the most complete version of the nameplate ever sold. It uses Mazda's 1.5L Skyactiv-G engine with a real six-speed automatic, delivering roughly 32–37 mpg combined. Standard low-speed automatic emergency braking and the best interior materials in Yaris history make it the safest and most refined choice. The five-door hatchback body added for 2019 also offers the most cargo versatility.

This is the pick for buyers who want the newest body, the most remaining service life, and the strongest safety content. It trades away the absolute lowest purchase price, as these list above older Toyota-built cars. Compared to the 2016–2018 iA sedan below, it is mechanically identical but costs more for the newer badge and hatchback body. Choose it when budget allows for the best overall experience.

2. 2016-2018 Scion iA sedan

The 2016–2018 Scion iA and Yaris iA sedan ranks second because it delivers the same Mazda-built engineering as the 2019–2020 car at a significant discount. It shares the 1.5L Skyactiv-G engine, six-speed automatic, and standard low-speed automatic emergency braking. Because the Scion badge carries almost no used-market recognition, these routinely list below equivalent-condition newer cars. This is the clear value arbitrage in the entire Yaris lineup.

This is for the budget-conscious buyer who wants the modern driving experience without paying the premium for the newest model year. It trades away the hatchback body style and the slightly updated infotainment of the 2019–2020 cars. Compared to the top pick, it offers the same chassis and safety for less money. Buy this when you want maximum capability per dollar spent.

3. 2015-2018 Toyota-built XP130

The 2015–2018 Toyota-built XP130 hatchback ranks third for being the best of the older, simpler lineage. It uses the durable 1.5L 1NZ-FE engine with port injection, avoiding direct-injection carbon buildup issues. The mid-cycle refresh brought a sharper front-end restyle and interior updates. The 2018 model is the last Toyota-built hatchback, making it the freshest of this dependable family.

This is for buyers who prioritize mechanical simplicity and low running costs over driving refinement. It trades away the six-speed automatic and better handling of the Mazda-built cars, settling for a four-speed automatic or five-speed manual. Compared to the iA above, it costs less but is noticeably less pleasant on longer drives. Choose it when you want a cheap, nearly indestructible commuter that any shop can service.

4. 2012-2014 Toyota-built XP130

The 2012–2014 Toyota-built XP130 ranks fourth as the sensible budget commuter. It is the third generation, slightly larger than its predecessor, with a five-door option added. The same 1NZ-FE engine and either four-speed automatic or five-speed manual make it extremely durable. These are among the cheapest genuinely reliable used cars available, with low-to-mid 30s combined fuel economy.

This is for the buyer whose primary concern is total cost of ownership. It trades away modern safety features like automatic emergency braking and any driving excitement. Compared to the refreshed 2015–2018 model above, it is older and plainer but mechanically identical and often cheaper. Choose it when you need dependable transportation at the absolute floor of the market.

5. 2009-2011 XP90 refreshed

The 2009–2011 XP90 refreshed ranks fifth for solidifying the Yaris's frugality reputation. It runs the same 1NZ-FE engine with a timing chain and port injection, ensuring low maintenance costs. Available as a three-door or five-door hatch plus a sedan, it offers honest, basic transportation. A documented example still delivers reliable service, though these cars are now aging.

This is for the ultra-budget buyer who accepts a spartan cabin and significant road noise. It trades away modern safety content and refinement entirely. Compared to the 2012–2014 XP130 above, it is older and smaller, but the drivetrain is just as durable. Only consider it at a low enough price, with rust and service history carefully inspected.

6. 2007-2008 XP90 first-gen

The 2007–2008 XP90 ranks sixth as the first U.S. Yaris, replacing the Echo. It features the same 1NZ-FE engine, but with a center-mounted instrument cluster and spartan equipment. It is slow by any modern standard, yet extremely durable. These are ultra-budget options that require hard inspection before purchase.

This is for the buyer who wants the cheapest possible entry into Toyota reliability. It trades away every modern comfort and safety feature, including stability control on some trims. Compared to the 2009–2011 refreshed model above, it is older and less refined, with no meaningful mechanical difference. Choose it only if the price is very low and the body is free of rust and neglect.

7. 2007-2012 XP90 sedan

The 2007–2012 XP90 sedan ranks seventh for buyers who specifically want a trunk. It shares the same 1NZ-FE mechanicals as the hatchback, with identical durability and fuel economy. The sedan body provides a marginally quieter cabin and a lockable trunk. It is equally basic inside, with no modern safety features.

This is for the buyer who prioritizes a traditional trunk over cargo versatility. It trades away the hatchback's flexible load floor and easier loading height. Compared to the hatchback versions above, it is mechanically identical but less practical for bulky items. Choose it only if a sedan body style is a firm requirement.

8. 2005-2006 Toyota Echo

The 2005–2006 Toyota Echo ranks eighth as the direct predecessor to the Yaris, offering the same 1NZ-FE engine family. It delivers nearly identical drivetrain durability at the absolute floor of the used market. However, it lacks every modern safety feature, including airbags on some base trims. It is not a Yaris, but shares the same engine story.

This is for the buyer whose only requirement is mechanical dependability at the lowest possible cost. It trades away all modern safety, comfort, and refinement. Compared to the first-gen XP90 above, it is older and even more basic, but the engine is just as tough. Choose it only if you accept its significant safety limitations.

9. High-mileage neglected Yaris

A high-mileage, neglected Yaris ranks ninth as a condition class rather than a specific year. While the 1NZ-FE and Skyactiv-G engines are durable, neglected examples are not. Rust in salt-belt regions, worn four-speed automatics, and dried seals from long storage can turn a bargain into a money pit. Service documentation predicts real-world reliability far better than the odometer reading.

This is for no one who wants a dependable car. It trades away peace of mind for a low sticker price that is often deceptive. Compared to a well-kept example with 140,000 miles, a 70,000-mile car with no records is the worse buy. Avoid these unless you are a skilled mechanic willing to take on significant risk.

10. 2020 Yaris with poor condition

The 2020 Yaris with poor condition ranks last because the newest model year cannot compensate for neglect. A well-kept 2016 iA is a better purchase than a neglected 2020 Yaris at the same price. Condition and documentation move the ownership-cost needle far more than model year does. Paying a premium for the newest year without checking condition is a common and costly mistake.

This is for the buyer who mistakenly assumes the newest badge guarantees quality. It trades away the reliability of a maintained car for the appearance of a newer one. Compared to the top-ranked 2019–2020 car, this example is the same model but with a compromised service history. Choose it only after a thorough inspection proves it is the exception, not the rule.

How we ranked these

This ranking measures real-world ownership value across every U.S. Yaris generation, weighting driving dynamics, fuel economy, safety content, and long-term durability. The Mazda-built 2019–2020 cars score highest for their Skyactiv-G engine, six-speed automatic, standard low-speed automatic emergency braking, and better chassis. The 2016–2018 Scion iA/Yaris iA sedan offers the same mechanical package at a lower used price, making it the best value.

Toyota-built XP130 hatchbacks rank lower due to the dated four-speed automatic and unrefined ride, despite excellent reliability.

Deliberately ignored are brand loyalty, subjective styling preferences, and the Toyota badge's perceived superiority. The nameplate's history shows that badge engineering misleads here—the 2018 Toyota-built hatchback is a worse car than the 2016 Mazda-built sedan. Also ignored are dealer reputation and warranty claims, since all cars are out of factory warranty.

The focus is purely on what a used-car buyer can verify and benefit from today: mechanical condition, safety features, and cost per mile, not marketing or heritage.

What to look for

What actually matters is build origin, not model year. Confirm the VIN and body style before negotiating: a 2018 Yaris could be a Toyota-built hatchback or a Mazda-built iA sedan, and they are not comparable. The Mazda-built cars (2016–2020) offer superior steering, a six-speed automatic, and standard low-speed automatic emergency braking—features that genuinely improve daily driving and safety.

The Toyota-built cars are simpler, cheaper to maintain, and still durable, but they lack modern safety tech and refinement. Prioritize service history over mileage; a 140,000-mile car with receipts beats a 70,000-mile one with no records.

The mistake most buyers make is assuming the Yaris is one continuous model. They read a review praising the Mazda-built car's handling, then buy a 2014 Toyota-built hatchback expecting the same experience. That mismatch leads to disappointment and a car that drones on the highway with a four-speed automatic. Another common error is ignoring rust in salt-belt regions—perforation is a walk-away on a car worth this little.

Finally, don't overpay for the newest year without checking condition; a well-kept 2016 iA is a better buy than a neglected 2020 Yaris at the same price.

Related questions

Is a Mazda-built Yaris still covered like a Toyota?

Yes—it was sold through Toyota dealers with Toyota's factory warranty and is serviced in the Toyota network. The engineering is Mazda's; the ownership and parts relationship is Toyota's. Independent shops treat it as a Mazda2 mechanically, which usually makes parts sourcing easier and cheaper, not harder.

Which Yaris has the most cargo space?

The five-door hatchbacks. The Toyota-built XP130 five-door and the 2019–2020 Mazda-built hatchback both fold their rear seats for a usefully flat load floor. The sedans trade that versatility for a locked, quieter trunk. If you move bulky items even occasionally, the hatch is the obvious choice.

Does the Yaris hold its value well?

Better than most discontinued economy cars, largely because the nameplate ended in the U.S. after 2020 and supply is capped. Strong fuel economy and a durable drivetrain keep demand steady among budget buyers, which supports resale more than a typical subcompact's depreciation curve would suggest.

Are parts hard to find for the Mazda-built cars?

No. They share components broadly with the Mazda2, which sold in volume globally. Filters, brakes, and routine wear items are widely stocked. The only mild friction is that some catalogs list parts under Mazda applications rather than Toyota ones, so search both.

What is the best-value Yaris on a tight budget?

The 2016–2018 Scion iA or Yaris iA sedan. It is the same Mazda-built car as the 2019–2020 Yaris sedan but carries badges with little used-market recognition, so it consistently lists for less. You get the Skyactiv engine, the six-speed automatic, and standard low-speed automatic emergency braking at a discount.

Are any Yaris model years worth avoiding outright?

No model year has a widespread systemic defect. The real risk is condition-based: neglected high-mileage cars, rust-belt bodies, and worn four-speed automatics on Toyota-built examples. Judge individual cars on maintenance records, rust, and shift quality rather than ruling out a year.

How good is the fuel economy, realistically?

Toyota-built models land in the low-to-mid 30s combined; Mazda-built models sit slightly higher, roughly 32–37 combined, with the six-speed automatic helping the highway figure meaningfully. Gentle driving on a well-maintained example reaches the upper end of those ranges; short cold trips in winter fall well below them.

FAQ

What is the difference between a Toyota-built and a Mazda-built Yaris?

Toyota-built cars (2007–2018 hatchbacks, 2007–2012 sedans) use the 1.5L 1NZ-FE with a four-speed automatic or five-speed manual—simple, port-injected, extremely durable, and unrefined. Mazda-built cars (2016–2020 sedan, 2019–2020 hatchback) are rebadged Mazda2s with the Skyactiv-G 1.5L, a six-speed automatic or manual, better handling, a nicer cabin, and standard low-speed automatic emergency braking.

Which Yaris model year is the most reliable?

Both lineages are strong. The Mazda-built 2016–2020 cars combine Mazda engineering with Toyota ownership support and add modern safety content, while early Toyota-built cars from 2007–2011 are famously durable but now old enough that condition dominates the reliability question. Service documentation predicts real-world reliability better than model year does.

Should I buy the sedan or the hatchback?

Within the Mazda-built lineage they are mechanically identical, so pick on body style: hatchback for cargo flexibility, sedan for a quieter, lockable trunk. Toyota-built hatchbacks are less refined but more common and cheaper. There is no reliability penalty either direction.

What is the best-value Yaris on a tight budget?

The 2016–2018 Scion iA or Yaris iA sedan. It is the same Mazda-built car as the 2019–2020 Yaris sedan but carries badges with little used-market recognition, so it consistently lists for less. You get the Skyactiv engine, the six-speed automatic, and standard low-speed automatic emergency braking at a discount.

Are any Yaris model years worth avoiding outright?

No model year has a widespread systemic defect. The real risk is condition-based: neglected high-mileage cars, rust-belt bodies, and worn four-speed automatics on Toyota-built examples. Judge individual cars on maintenance records, rust, and shift quality rather than ruling out a year.

How good is the fuel economy, realistically?

Toyota-built models land in the low-to-mid 30s combined; Mazda-built models sit slightly higher, roughly 32–37 combined, with the six-speed automatic helping the highway figure meaningfully. Gentle driving on a well-maintained example reaches the upper end of those ranges; short cold trips in winter fall well below them.

Is the Yaris good for a new driver?

Yes, especially the Mazda-built 2019–2020 models with standard low-speed automatic emergency braking—a rare feature in this class and genuinely valuable for a first car. The Toyota-built cars are also safe but lack that tech. Both are easy to park, cheap to insure, and forgiving to drive, making them excellent learner cars.

What should I check on a used Yaris before buying?

Confirm build origin via VIN. Inspect for rust in rocker panels, wheel arches, and rear suspension mounts. Test the automatic transmission for flaring or shudder when warm. Check the clutch on manuals. Verify the pre-collision system on Mazda-built cars isn't faulting. Service records beat odometer readings every time.

Sources

• https://www.toyota.com/
• https://www.fueleconomy.gov/
• https://www.caranddriver.com/
• https://www.edmunds.com/
• https://www.kbb.com/
• https://www.motortrend.com/
• https://www.consumerreports.org/

Related on PULSE

• [More best toyota yaris model years (ranked) rankings and buying guides](/knowledge)
• [PULSE Tools and calculators](/tools)
• [Everything on PULSE RevOps](/)