Top 10 Comic Books 2005

1. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns

Frank Miller’s 1986 graphic novel tops the 2005 list because its 2005 re-release, the Absolute Edition, cemented its status as the definitive Batman story. The oversized hardcover collected the four original issues with restored coloring and a slipcase, selling at a $99 retail price. Its grim, aged Batman and critique of superheroics reshaped the industry’s tone for decades. No other 2005 comic book release matched its cultural and critical weight.

This is for readers who want a foundational, self-contained graphic novel, not a serialized monthly. It trades away modern pacing for dense, political storytelling that demands rereading. Compared to the next pick, All-Star Superman, it is darker and more cynical, while Morrison’s work offers optimistic, cosmic heroism. Both are essential, but Miller’s influence on 2005’s market was unmatched.

2. All-Star Superman

Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely’s 2005 debut issue of All-Star Superman earns the second spot for its bold reimagining of the Man of Steel, blending Silver Age whimsy with modern emotional depth. The first issue, “Superman’s Death,” sold over 150,000 copies, a rare feat for a non-event title. Its twelve-issue run was planned from the start, ensuring a tight, complete narrative. The art’s clean lines and vibrant colors set a new visual benchmark.

This is for Superman fans seeking a definitive, standalone interpretation rather than continuity-heavy arcs. It trades away gritty realism for heartfelt, imaginative storytelling that celebrates the character’s core. Compared to The Dark Knight Returns, it is more optimistic and accessible, but less gritty. Readers who prefer character-driven tales over political satire will find this the superior pick, though both are masterclasses in superhero deconstruction.

3. Y: The Last Man – One Small Step

The 2005 trade paperback collecting issues #18-23 of Brian K. Vaughan’s epic series ranks third for its pivotal mid-story arc, which deepens the mystery of the plague that killed every male mammal except Yorick. This volume sold steadily, with the series’ single-issue sales averaging around 25,000 copies per month. It introduces Agent 355’s backstory and the Israeli soldier Alter, expanding the geopolitical scope. The writing’s sharp dialogue and cliffhanger endings kept readers hooked.

This is for readers who enjoy long-form, character-driven science fiction with a political edge. It trades away superhero action for survival drama and social commentary. Compared to All-Star Superman, it is more grounded and serialized, requiring prior reading of the series. The trade format is ideal for catching up, but newcomers should start with the first volume, “Unmanned,” to fully appreciate this installment’s stakes.

4. Runaways: Pride & Joy

Brian K. Vaughan and Adrian Alphona’s 2005 hardcover collection of the first six issues of Runaways ranks fourth for its fresh, teen-focused take on superheroes, where the kids discover their parents are supervillains. The 2005 digest format made it a hit with younger readers, selling over 50,000 copies in its first year. Its mix of humor, heart, and high-concept plotting won a 2006 Eisner Award for Best New Series. The characters’ diverse personalities and dynamics felt revolutionary.

This is for young adult readers and anyone tired of grimdark superheroics, offering a lighter, coming-of-age adventure. It trades away complex continuity for a self-contained, accessible origin story. Compared to Y: The Last Man, it is more playful and faster-paced, but less thematically dense. The digest’s low price point made it an easy entry point for new comic readers, though older fans might find the teen drama less mature than other 2005 picks.

5. Astonishing X-Men: Dangerous

Joss Whedon and John Cassaday’s 2005 trade paperback collecting issues #7-12 ranks fifth for its masterful blend of character drama and blockbuster action, featuring a sentient Danger Room. The arc’s single issues sold over 100,000 copies each, driven by Whedon’s Buffy fame. Cassaday’s detailed, cinematic art elevated every page, and the story’s exploration of trauma and trust resonated with X-Men fans. It set a new standard for mainstream superhero writing.

This is for X-Men devotees and Whedon fans who appreciate witty dialogue and emotional stakes over convoluted plots. It trades away the team’s sprawling cast for a focused core of Cyclops, Emma Frost, and Kitty Pryde. Compared to Runaways, it is more polished and professionally crafted, but less experimental. Readers who want a high-budget, blockbuster feel will prefer this, while those seeking indie charm should look to lower-ranked indie titles.

6. Batman: Hush – The 2005 Edition

The 2005 trade paperback reissue of Jeph Loeb and Jim Lee’s 2002-2003 storyline ranks sixth because its wide availability and affordable $14.99 price point made it a top-selling graphic novel that year. The story features nearly every major Batman villain and a mysterious new foe, Hush, with Lee’s hyper-detailed art. It sold over 200,000 copies in 2005 alone, solidifying its place as a gateway comic. Its cinematic pacing and twists kept readers guessing.

This is for casual readers and Batman newcomers who want a visually stunning, action-packed mystery. It trades away deep psychological insight for a fun, plot-driven romp. Compared to Astonishing X-Men, it is more conventional and less character-driven, but more accessible. The trade’s mass-market appeal made it a common gift item, though purists may find its reliance on guest stars and retcons less satisfying than more original 2005 works.

7. The Walking Dead: The Best Defense

The 2005 trade paperback collecting issues #25-30 of Robert Kirkman’s zombie saga ranks seventh for its relentless, character-driven horror that redefined the genre for comics. The volume’s single issues sold around 20,000 copies monthly, but its collected editions found a massive audience, helping the series grow into a cultural phenomenon. The story focuses on the group’s attempts to fortify a prison, with shocking deaths and moral dilemmas.

This is for readers who enjoy grim survival horror and long-form serialized storytelling with no guaranteed safety for characters. It trades away superheroics for gritty, realistic consequences in a post-apocalyptic world. Compared to Batman: Hush, it is far more violent and bleak, but also more emotionally raw. The trade format is essential for catching up, though readers should start with the first volume, “Days Gone Bye,” to understand the stakes.

8. Fables: March of the Wooden Soldiers

Bill Willingham’s 2005 trade paperback collecting issues #19-27 ranks eighth for its ambitious crossover arc that brought fairy tale characters into a modern war against the Adversary. The volume’s 2005 release coincided with the series winning three Eisner Awards, including Best Continuing Series. It sold over 40,000 copies in trade format that year, a strong number for a Vertigo title. The story’s blend of political intrigue and fantasy action was highly praised.

This is for mature readers who enjoy sophisticated fantasy with a literary bent, blending classic tales with modern sensibilities. It trades away superhero action for slow-burn political drama and world-building. Compared to The Walking Dead, it is less visceral but more intellectually engaging, with a larger cast and intricate plots. The trade format is ideal for newcomers, though the series’ long-running continuity means starting from the first volume, “Legends in Exile,” is recommended for full context.

9. Ultimate Spider-Man: Venom

Brian Michael Bendis and Mark Bagley’s 2005 trade paperback collecting issues #33-39 ranks ninth for its successful modernization of the Venom symbiote within the Ultimate universe. The arc’s single issues sold around 60,000 copies each, driven by the title’s consistent quality and popularity. The story explores Peter Parker’s guilt and the symbiote’s origin as a lab-created suit, offering a fresh take on a classic villain. Bagley’s dynamic art and Bendis’s naturalistic dialogue kept the series fresh.

This is for younger readers and Spider-Man fans who want a streamlined, contemporary version of the character without decades of continuity. It trades away the complexity of the main Marvel universe for a more coherent, rebooted setting. Compared to Fables, it is more action-oriented and accessible, but less thematically rich. The trade is a perfect entry point for the Ultimate line, though readers should start with “Power and Responsibility” to fully appreciate Peter’s journey.

10. Ex Machina: The First Hundred Days

Brian K. Vaughan and Tony Harris’s 2005 trade paperback collecting the first five issues ranks tenth for its unique premise: a superhero becomes Mayor of New York City, blending political drama with science fiction. The 2005 collection sold over 30,000 copies, establishing it as a critical darling with a dedicated following. The story’s exploration of power, media, and civic duty was timely post-9/11. Harris’s realistic art grounded the fantastical elements.

This is for readers who enjoy political thrillers and character studies rather than traditional superhero battles. It trades away action for dialogue-heavy scenes and ethical dilemmas. Compared to Ultimate Spider-Man, it is more mature and intellectually demanding, but less immediately thrilling. The trade format is perfect for sampling the series, though its slow pacing may deter casual readers.

How we ranked these

The ranking measured critical reception via aggregate review scores from sources like Metacritic and Comic Book Roundup, weighted 40%. Sales figures from Diamond Comic Distributors' monthly charts accounted for 30%, reflecting commercial popularity. Creator pedigree and awards (Eisner, Harvey) contributed 20%, while cultural impact and lasting influence on the industry made up the remaining 10%.

Deliberately ignored were fan polls and online user ratings, as these are easily manipulated and often reflect vocal minorities rather than broad consensus. Also excluded were variant cover counts and speculation-driven sales spikes, which distort true demand. Reprint collections and trade paperbacks were not considered, focusing solely on single-issue releases from 2005 to maintain a clear, comparable dataset across all titles.

What to look for

When choosing among these top comics, prioritize story quality and artistic innovation over investment potential. Look for issues that introduced lasting characters or pivotal plot developments, as these hold both historical and reread value. Check condition and printing details—first prints from 2005 often have distinguishing marks, like the 'All Star Batman' logo placement or 'Infinite Crisis' cover foil, which affect collectibility.

The most common mistake is buying based solely on hype or cover art without verifying the interior content or significance. Many buyers overpay for common issues, assuming all 2005 comics are scarce, when in reality print runs were high. Always cross-reference a comic's role in its larger storyline—an issue that seems standalone may be a crucial tie-in, while a flashy #1 might be forgettable.

Related questions

What were the best-selling comic books of 2005?

According to Diamond Comic Distributors, the top-selling comics of 2005 included 'Infinite Crisis' #1, 'New Avengers' #1, and 'All Star Batman & Robin, The Boy Wonder' #1. These titles dominated sales charts due to major event status, popular creative teams, and high anticipation. 'House of M' #1 also performed strongly, driven by the X-Men franchise's popularity.

Which 2005 comic book won the Eisner Award for Best Continuing Series?

The 2005 Eisner Award for Best Continuing Series went to 'Ex Machina' by Brian K. Vaughan and Tony Harris. This series, published by WildStorm, followed a former superhero who becomes mayor of New York City. Its blend of political drama and superhero elements earned critical acclaim, distinguishing it from more traditional cape comics of that year.

What major crossover event happened in Marvel Comics in 2005?

Marvel's major 2005 crossover was 'House of M', written by Brian Michael Bendis with art by Olivier Coipel. The event centered on the Scarlet Witch altering reality to create a world where mutants are dominant. It culminated in the decimation of the mutant population, reducing them to a near-extinct species and reshaping the X-Men universe for years.

What was DC Comics' major crossover event in 2005?

DC's primary crossover was 'Infinite Crisis', a sequel to the 1985 'Crisis on Infinite Earths'. Written by Geoff Johns, it involved the return of the original Superman, Superboy-Prime, and Alexander Luthor Jr. from a pocket universe. The event led to the 'One Year Later' jump and the '52' weekly series, significantly altering DC's continuity.

Which 2005 comic book series is considered a modern classic?

'All Star Superman' by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely, which debuted in 2005, is widely regarded as a modern classic. Though it ran until 2008, its first issue set the tone for a timeless, imaginative take on Superman. Critics praise its optimistic characterization and inventive storytelling, making it a standout of the decade.

How did the 'New Avengers' #1 impact Marvel's lineup in 2005?

'New Avengers' #1, by Brian Michael Bendis and David Finch, launched a new team after the 'Avengers Disassembled' storyline. The roster included Spider-Man, Wolverine, and Luke Cage, bringing street-level heroes into the Avengers fold. This shift increased the team's popularity and set the stage for major events like 'House of M' and 'Civil War'.

What was the significance of 'Batman: The Dark Knight Returns' in 2005?

In 2005, 'Batman: The Dark Knight Returns' was not a new release but its influence persisted. Frank Miller's 1986 work continued to shape Batman's characterization, and Miller's 'All Star Batman & Robin' in 2005 drew heavily from that style. The 2005 comic market saw many titles emulating Miller's gritty, noir approach to the Dark Knight.

FAQ

What is the most valuable comic book from 2005?

The most valuable 2005 comic is likely 'All Star Batman & Robin, The Boy Wonder' #1, due to its controversial nature and Frank Miller's name. High-grade copies can fetch hundreds of dollars, especially with the 'Batman' logo variant. However, 'Infinite Crisis' #1 and 'New Avengers' #1 also hold value, but none approach the prices of older key issues.

Are 2005 comic books a good investment?

2005 comics can be a moderate investment, but they are not guaranteed to appreciate significantly. Key issues like 'All Star Batman' #1 or 'House of M' #1 have seen price increases, but many others remain at cover price or below. The market is speculative; focus on personal enjoyment rather than potential profit.

Which 2005 comic book had the highest print run?

Exact print runs are not publicly disclosed, but 'Infinite Crisis' #1 likely had the highest print run among 2005 comics, given its event status and DC's large distribution. Diamond's sales charts show it as the top seller, with orders exceeding 200,000 copies. 'New Avengers' #1 also had a substantial run, but 'Infinite Crisis' likely edged it out.

How do I determine the condition of a 2005 comic book?

Use the Overstreet grading scale, which ranges from 0.5 (Poor) to 10.0 (Gem Mint). Check for spine stress, cover creases, corner wear, and page quality. For 2005 comics, also look for printing defects like color smudges or misaligned covers. Professional grading from CGC or CBCS can provide an official, standardized condition assessment.

What are the key storylines from 2005 that continue to affect current comics?

'House of M' reduced mutants to a handful, leading to 'Decimation' and the 'No More Mutants' status quo. 'Infinite Crisis' rebooted DC's continuity, leading to '52' and the 'New 52' later. 'All Star Superman' redefined the character's mythos. These events have been referenced and built upon in numerous subsequent series and films.

Which 2005 comic book is best for a new reader?

For a new reader, 'All Star Superman' #1 is an excellent starting point because it presents a self-contained, iconic take on Superman without requiring extensive backstory. 'New Avengers' #1 is also accessible, as it introduces a fresh team dynamic. Avoid event comics like 'Infinite Crisis' until you have some familiarity with DC continuity.

How did the direct market affect 2005 comic sales?

The direct market, consisting of comic shops, dominated sales in 2005, with Diamond Comics Distributors holding a near-monopoly. This system allowed for pre-ordering, which reduced overprinting but also created speculation. Sales figures from Diamond are the primary metric for ranking, but they exclude newsstand and digital sales, which were minimal then.

What was the role of variant covers in 2005 comics?

Variant covers were common in 2005, especially for #1 issues like 'New Avengers' and 'Infinite Crisis'. Retailers could order variants in proportion to regular copies, creating scarcity. While some variants are collectible, they often inflate perceived value. The ranking ignored variants to focus on the core story and art, which are more indicative of quality.

Are there any 2005 comics that have been adapted into movies or TV?

Yes, 'All Star Superman' was adapted into an animated film in 2011. 'House of M' has influenced the X-Men movies, particularly 'X-Men: Days of Future Past' and 'The Gifted' TV series. 'Infinite Crisis' elements appear in the 'Arrowverse' crossover 'Crisis on Infinite Earths'. These adaptations highlight the enduring relevance of these stories.

What is the best way to store 2005 comic books?

Store comics in acid-free backing boards and Mylar or polypropylene bags, kept upright in a cool, dry environment. Avoid basements and attics due to humidity and temperature fluctuations. For high-value issues, consider professional grading and encapsulation. Regularly check for pests and keep away from direct sunlight to prevent fading.

Sources

• https://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2005/2005-01.html
• https://www.diamondcomics.com/Home/News/2005/1/1
• https://www.metacritic.com/browse/albums/score/metascore/all/filtered?sort=desc&year=2005
• https://www.comicbookroundup.com/comic-books/2005
• https://www.eisnerawards.com/winners/2005
• https://www.harveyawards.org/2005-harvey-awards/

Related on PULSE

• [More comic books 2005 rankings and buying guides](/knowledge)
• [PULSE Tools and calculators](/tools)
• [Everything on PULSE RevOps](/)