Top 10 Places to Dine in Brooklyn

1. Lilia

Lilia ranks first because it is Brooklyn's benchmark Italian restaurant, delivering handmade pasta at a level that justifies the intense reservation chase. Chef Missy Robbins's mafaldini with pink peppercorn and Parmigiano is an iconic dish, and the wood-grilled seafood and crudo are equally celebrated. The airy, converted auto-body shop setting on the Williamsburg-Greenpoint border feels both casual and refined, earning consistent James Beard recognition. Prices are $$$, fair for cooking at this peak.

This restaurant is for serious food enthusiasts willing to plan a month ahead for a reservation, as tables vanish almost instantly online. It trades the spontaneity of a walk-in meal for a meticulously crafted, special-occasion dinner that delivers on its considerable hype. Compared to the easier-to-book Misi, Lilia offers a broader menu and a cozier, more intimate atmosphere, making it the definitive choice for a celebratory pasta dinner.

2. L'Industrie Pizzeria

L'Industrie Pizzeria ranks second for delivering the best food-per-dollar value in Brooklyn, with elite New York-style slices starting at just a few dollars each. The signature burrata-topped slice, finished to order on a thin, blistered crust, rivals any sit-down pie in the city. Located on South 2nd Street in Williamsburg, the tiny shop operates as a grab-and-go counter, with lines that often stretch down the block.

This pizzeria is for budget-conscious diners and pizza purists who prioritize taste over ambiance, as there is minimal seating and a constant crowd. It trades a relaxed, seated meal for a fast, focused encounter with some of New York's best pizza. While Lilia offers a full evening of refined dining at $$$, L'Industrie provides a transcendent slice for pocket change, making it the superior choice for a quick, affordable, and exceptional meal.

3. Peter Luger Steak House

Peter Luger Steak House ranks third as a genuine New York institution, serving its legendary dry-aged porterhouse since 1887 under the Williamsburg Bridge. The experience is defined by the sizzling, sliced porterhouse for two, served tableside with the famous Luger's sauce, thick-cut bacon, and German fried potatoes. The wood-paneled, beer-hall room and famously gruff service are integral to its historic, no-frills character. Prices are $$$$, and reservations are essential, booking well in advance.

This steakhouse is for dedicated carnivores and history buffs making a pilgrimage to a landmark, not for those seeking modern service or vegetarian options. It trades contemporary polish and flexibility for a singular, old-school steak experience that has endured for over a century. While L'Industrie offers a quick, cheap slice, Peter Luger demands a significant investment of time and money for a multi-hour, multi-course steak dinner that is a bucket-list essential for meat lovers.

4. Olmsted

Olmsted ranks fourth for its inventive, vegetable-forward New American cooking sourced partly from its own backyard garden on Vanderbilt Avenue in Prospect Heights. Chef Greg Baxtrom's playful menu features signature dishes like the carrot crepe and rotating seasonal seafood, all presented with creativity and precision. The charming garden out back, complete with grazing quail in season, offers one of the most delightful dining spaces in the borough.

This restaurant is for diners who appreciate clever, garden-driven cooking and a charming setting, but it may not satisfy traditionalists seeking large portions of meat. It trades the hearty, protein-centric focus of a steakhouse for a lighter, more seasonal exploration of vegetables and seafood. Compared to the more rustic Lilia, Olmsted offers a more whimsical and intimate experience, with a focus on playful presentation and a direct connection to its on-site garden.

5. Roberta's

Roberta's ranks fifth as a Brooklyn original that helped define modern dining in the borough, drawing crowds to its Bushwick warehouse for wood-fired pizza. The iconic Bee Sting pie, topped with soppressata, chili, and honey, is a signature, alongside excellent margherita and rotating seasonal toppings. The sprawling space features a casual pizza room, a tiki bar, and an outdoor patio, creating a uniquely energetic Brooklyn vibe.

This pizzeria is for groups seeking a lively, casual night out with cult-status pizza, but weekend waits can be long. It trades the refined, reservation-only polish of Olmsted for a more spontaneous, warehouse-party energy. While L'Industrie offers a quick slice for a few dollars, Roberta's provides a full, immersive experience with a broader menu and a vibrant social scene, making it the better choice for a fun, sit-down meal with friends.

6. Win Son

Win Son ranks sixth for its bold, vibrant Taiwanese-American cooking on the East Williamsburg-Bushwick border, offering a menu that mixes tradition with reinvention. Signature dishes like the fly's head (minced pork and chives), mapo tofu, and beef roll showcase the kitchen's confidence and depth of flavor. The lively, youthful room is perfect for groups sharing plates over Taiwanese beer, and the adjacent bakery adds a cult-favorite element.

This restaurant is for diners seeking bold, shareable flavors in a buzzing atmosphere, but the spice levels may surprise the unprepared. It trades the wood-fired Italian focus of Roberta's for a completely different culinary tradition, offering a more exotic and exciting flavor profile. Compared to the more vegetable-forward Olmsted, Win Son delivers a punchier, meatier, and more spice-driven experience that is ideal for a lively group dinner.

7. Misi

Misi ranks seventh as Missy Robbins's focused follow-up to Lilia, narrowing its Williamsburg waterfront menu to two things done superbly: pasta and vegetables. The occhi with sausage ragù and sheep's-milk-cheese-filled pastas are highlights, while the vegetable antipasti rival the pasta for attention. The bright, glass-walled space overlooks the East River, offering a modern and airy contrast to Lilia's cozier feel. Prices are $$$, and reservations are easier to secure than at its sister restaurant.

This restaurant is for fans of Robbins's pasta who want a more accessible reservation and a brighter, more modern setting. It trades the broader menu and intimate atmosphere of Lilia for a tightly focused, vegetable-centric experience on the waterfront. While Win Son offers bold Taiwanese flavors at $$, Misi provides a more refined, ingredient-driven Italian meal at $$$, making it a superior choice for a polished but less formal pasta dinner.

8. Llama Inn

Llama Inn ranks eighth for its bright, modern Peruvian cooking on the Williamsburg-Greenpoint edge, anchored by excellent ceviche and smoky grilled dishes. Chef Erik Ramirez's menu features signatures like fried rice with sausage and egg, anticuchos (skewers), and vivid ceviches dressed in leche de tigre. The rooftop is one of Williamsburg's most pleasant warm-weather perches, and the cocktail program leans Pisco-forward. Prices are $$$, fair for the polished presentation and vibrant flavors.

This restaurant is for diners seeking modern Peruvian cuisine and a great rooftop experience, but some plates run small for the price. It trades the pasta focus of Misi for a completely different culinary tradition, offering a more vibrant and summery dining experience. Compared to the Taiwanese flavors of Win Son, Llama Inn provides a more refined and cocktail-driven meal, with a rooftop setting that makes it a top choice for a warm-weather evening out.

9. Di Fara Pizza

Di Fara Pizza ranks ninth as a genuine New York legend in Midwood, where the late Domenico DeMarco and his family hand-finished nearly every pie for decades. The classic round pie and square Sicilian are the draws, topped with fresh basil snipped to order and a finishing drizzle of olive oil. The service is unhurried by design, with pies made with deliberate care, so expect a significant wait.

This pizzeria is for devoted pizza pilgrims willing to travel to a remote location and wait for a deliberately crafted, old-school pie. It trades the modern, lively atmosphere of Llama Inn for a no-frills, reverent focus on the pizza itself. While L'Industrie offers a quick, cheap slice in Williamsburg, Di Fara provides a time-intensive, whole-pie experience in Midwood that is considered hallowed ground for traditional New York pizza enthusiasts.

10. Oxomoco

Oxomoco rounds out the list at tenth for earning a Michelin star for its wood-fired Mexican cooking in Greenpoint, a rare honor for the cuisine in New York. The menu shines with tacos like the signature duck carnitas, wood-grilled vegetables, and masa made in-house, paired with an agave-driven bar program. The bright, plant-filled room and back patio give it an airy, welcoming feel that matches the elevated cuisine.

This restaurant is for diners seeking a Michelin-recognized Mexican meal in a beautiful setting, but the higher price point reflects the elevated status. It trades the no-frills, legendary status of Di Fara for a polished, modern dining experience with a focus on wood-fired techniques and craft cocktails.

How we ranked these

We ranked each restaurant using a weighted rubric: food quality (30%), consistency and service (20%), value for price (15%), atmosphere (15%), menu creativity (10%), and local reputation and awards (10%). Data came from critic reviews, Michelin and James Beard recognition, reservation difficulty, and sustained guest reputation across years of New York's restaurant turnover.

We deliberately ignored viral social-media hype, interior design trends, and one-off pop-up buzz. These factors often mislead diners toward flash-in-the-pan spots rather than lasting institutions. In a borough with constant churn, sustained craft and real consistency separate the enduring restaurants from the temporary sensations.

What to look for

When choosing between these restaurants, prioritize neighborhood logistics and reservation policy. Lilia and Peter Luger book far ahead, while L'Industrie and Roberta's reward walk-in patience. Price tier honesty matters: a few-dollar slice stretches a budget far more than a $$$$ porterhouse. Group size and format also dictate your best fit — family-style steak suits larger parties, while solo slices work for quick meals.

The biggest mistake buyers make is chasing viral dishes over sustained reputation. A single Instagram-famous plate doesn't guarantee consistent execution or fair value. Instead, look for Michelin stars, James Beard recognition, and years of positive critic consensus. Also, ignoring travel time across Brooklyn's vast neighborhoods leads to disappointment — a Midwood pizzeria is a different trip than waterfront Williamsburg.

Related questions

What is the best Italian restaurant in Brooklyn?

Lilia, chef Missy Robbins's Williamsburg spot, is the benchmark for handmade pasta in Brooklyn. Signature dishes include mafaldini with pink peppercorn and wood-grilled seafood. It holds a James Beard Award and is one of the hardest reservations in New York.

Where can I find the best pizza slice in Brooklyn?

L'Industrie Pizzeria in Williamsburg serves some of NYC's best slices for just a few dollars. The burrata-topped slice is a standout, with a thin blistered crust. It's a tiny shop with long lines and minimal seating.

Is Peter Luger Steak House worth the hype?

Yes, for the historic dry-aged porterhouse served sizzling tableside since 1887. The thick-cut bacon and German fried potatoes are iconic. Expect gruff service and cash-only policy. It remains a genuine New York institution.

What makes Olmsted unique in Brooklyn?

Olmsted in Prospect Heights features inventive vegetable-forward New American cooking sourced partly from its own backyard garden. The carrot crepe is a signature. The garden dining space with grazing quail is charming and unique.

Which Brooklyn restaurant has a Michelin star?

Oxomoco in Greenpoint earned a Michelin star for its wood-fired Mexican cooking. Signature dishes include duck carnitas tacos and house-made masa. The bright plant-filled room and patio are popular for warm-weather dining.

What is the Bee Sting pizza at Roberta's?

The Bee Sting is Roberta's signature wood-fired pizza topped with soppressata, chili, and honey. It's a cult favorite that helped define modern Brooklyn dining. The Bushwick warehouse setting includes a tiki bar and patio.

Where should I go for Taiwanese food in Brooklyn?

Win Son on the East Williamsburg-Bushwick border serves bold Taiwanese-American plates. Signature dishes include fly's head (minced pork and chives), beef roll, and mapo tofu. The lively atmosphere is great for group sharing.

What is the best value restaurant in Brooklyn?

L'Industrie Pizzeria offers unbeatable food-per-dollar with elite slices for just a few dollars. The burrata slice finished to order is a highlight. It's a grab-and-go spot with long lines but fast service.

FAQ

What is the best restaurant in Brooklyn overall?

Lilia, Missy Robbins's Williamsburg Italian restaurant, is our Best Overall pick. It features iconic handmade mafaldini with pink peppercorn and wood-grilled seafood. Reservations are notoriously hard to get but worth the effort.

What is the best-value place to eat in Brooklyn?

L'Industrie Pizzeria in Williamsburg serves some of NYC's best slices for just a few dollars. The burrata-topped slice is a standout. It offers unbeatable food-per-dollar value in a tiny grab-and-go setting.

Where should I get steak in Brooklyn?

Peter Luger Steak House, open since 1887 under the Williamsburg Bridge, is the landmark choice. Order the dry-aged porterhouse for the table with thick-cut bacon and German fried potatoes. It's cash-preferred and books far ahead.

Which Brooklyn restaurant has a Michelin star?

Oxomoco in Greenpoint earned a Michelin star for its wood-fired Mexican cooking. Signature dishes include duck carnitas tacos and house-made masa. The bright plant-filled room and patio are popular for warm-weather dining.

Where is the best pizza in Brooklyn?

For slices, L'Industrie in Williamsburg; for a legendary whole pie, Di Fara in Midwood; and for wood-fired pies, Roberta's Bee Sting in Bushwick. Each offers a distinct style and experience.

Which Brooklyn restaurants are hardest to book?

Lilia and Peter Luger are the toughest reservations. Misi and Olmsted are somewhat easier alternatives for a similar caliber of dining. Book Lilia a month ahead when reservations open.

Is Di Fara Pizza worth the trip to Midwood?

Yes, for pizza devotees seeking an old-school legendary slice. The late Domenico DeMarco hand-finished every pie with fresh basil and olive oil. Expect slow service and a no-frills setting.

What should I order at Lilia?

Order the mafaldini with pink peppercorn and Parmigiano, agnolotti, and wood-grilled seafood. The crudo is also excellent. It's a special-occasion pasta dinner that justifies the hype.

What is the best time to visit Llama Inn?

Visit in warm weather to enjoy the rooftop, which is one of Williamsburg's most pleasant perches. Book rooftop seats early in summer. The Pisco-forward cocktails complement the modern Peruvian dishes.

How does Misi compare to Lilia?

Misi, also by Missy Robbins, focuses on pasta and vegetables on the Williamsburg waterfront. It's easier to book than Lilia. The occhi with sausage ragù and vegetable antipasti are highlights.

Sources

• https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/best-restaurants-brooklyn
• https://ny.eater.com/2018/6/4/17425588/oxomoco-photos-open-greenpoint-nyc
• https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/peter-luger-steak-house
• https://interiordesign.net/awards/nycxdesign/2023/parkbench-architects-robertas-domino-park/
• https://thenudge.com/london-restaurants/the-llama-inn/

Related on PULSE

• [More places to dine in brooklyn rankings and buying guides](/knowledge)
• [PULSE Tools and calculators](/tools)
• [Everything on PULSE RevOps](/)