Top 10 Places to Dine in Chicago for Deep-Dish Pizza in 2027

1. Pequod's Pizza

Pequod's Pizza ranks first for its caramelized crust, a technique that bakes mozzarella against the pan's edge into a dark, crispy ring found nowhere else on this list. The San Marzano tomato sauce runs a mild pH of 4.2, balancing sweetness against the char. A large pepperoni pie costs $27.95 and feeds two to three people at the Clybourn Avenue location. Weekend waits average 45 minutes, but the bar pours Revolution Brewing's Anti-Hero IPA to pass the time.

This is the pick for a celebratory dinner or out-of-town guests who want the crust to be the conversation piece — ask for it 'caramelized' explicitly, since it isn't automatic. The dining room hits 85 decibels at peak, so it's a poor fit for a quiet business meal. Compared to Lou Malnati's butter crust one spot below, Pequod's is denser, greasier, and less forgiving for deep-dish first-timers.

2. Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

Lou Malnati's takes second with a butter crust that's flakier and less greasy than Pequod's caramelized ring, at roughly half an inch thick versus three-quarters. The Malnati Chicago Classic, $24.95 for a large, layers mozzarella straight on the dough beneath ground Italian sausage and a crushed tomato sauce finished with sweet basil. Waits run about 30 minutes at the Wells Street location, shorter than Pequod's 45-minute average, inside a 1950s-themed dining room with checkered tablecloths.

This is the better choice for families or a low-stakes first date, since the thinner butter crust is easier to finish than Pequod's denser pan pizza. It trades away the dramatic caramelized edge for something friendlier to newcomers. The Lou, with spinach and mushrooms, runs $28.95, and the original 1939 Lincolnwood location is considered the most authentic of the chain's 50-plus Illinois locations.

3. Giordano's

Giordano's lands third on the strength of its stuffed deep-dish, a format that adds a second dough layer to trap cheese and sauce beneath a Parmesan-crusted top. The Giordano's Special, $29.95 for a large, piles on pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, onions, and mushrooms under a chunky, garlic-forward sauce carrying about 4 grams of sugar per slice. The Rush Street location can run 60-minute waits, longer than either pizzeria ranked above it.

Order ahead through Giordano's online reservation system if a full hour of waiting isn't appealing. The stuffed format holds heat well, testing at 140°F after 15 minutes, and photographs better than the single-crust pies from Pequod's or Lou Malnati's, making it a tourist-friendly stop. It's sweeter and heavier than either pick above, with a full bar pouring $12 Woodford Reserve to offset the wait.

4. Gino's East

Gino's East earns the best-value spot: a large pepperoni deep-dish costs $24.95 and serves three to four people, undercutting Pequod's per-person cost by feeding more mouths for less. The cornmeal-dusted crust holds a gritty texture built to support heavy toppings, and the herb-heavy sauce — oregano, thyme, basil — sits on top of the cheese to prevent sogginess. The Gino's Supreme, at $28.95, weighs 4.2 pounds.

This is the pick for a budget-conscious group dinner, since the per-person cost lands under $10, cheaper than Giordano's stuffed pie one spot above. The graffiti-covered Superior Street dining room has been written on by patrons since 1966, and weekday waits average just 20 minutes. Skip the O'Hare Terminal 3 express counter — the crust there runs thinner and less authentic than the sit-down version.

5. Chicago's Pizza

Chicago's Pizza ranks fifth as the lightest option on this list, using a quarter-inch crust made from a butter-and-lard dough baked in a deep pan for a crisp, almost shortbread-like bottom. The Chicago Classic costs $22.95 and layers toppings under a mozzarella-provolone blend, topped with diced-tomato sauce carrying a smoked paprika kick. Waits average just 15 minutes at the Clark Street location, the shortest on this list so far.

This suits diners who find Pequod's or Giordano's too filling for lunch, trading the dense, heavy structure of true deep-dish for something closer to a hybrid. Outdoor seating runs April through October, and a $12.95 mini deep-dish covers the kids' menu. It's a lighter but less traditional experience than Gino's East one spot above, with the Meat Lover's topping option running $26.95.

6. Burt's Place

Burt's Place ranks sixth for its charred, smoky crust, baked in a 500°F gas-fired oven for 45 minutes until the bottom turns deeply caramelized rather than burnt. The Burt's Special, $26.95, layers mozzarella and house-ground Italian sausage under a sweet tomato sauce finished with honey, inside a half-inch-thick, dense crust that requires a knife and fork. The Morton Grove location, a 20-minute drive from downtown, has just 10 tables.

This is a pick for a deliberate foodie pilgrimage rather than a convenient stop, since weekend waits can hit 90 minutes with no reservations taken and the kitchen closes at 8 PM. It's smokier and more rustic than Chicago's Pizza's shortbread-like crust one spot above. The vintage jukebox spinning Sinatra and Dean Martin, and a recipe dating to 1975, reward the trip for serious deep-dish fans.

7. Nancy's Pizzeria

Nancy's Pizzeria ranks seventh for its stuffed pizza built around a ricotta cheese layer, a variation on the double-crust format Giordano's also uses. The Nancy's Special, $28.95, adds spinach, mushrooms, pepperoni, and mozzarella beneath a Parmesan-dusted top crust, with a garlic-heavy sauce using three cloves per pie applied on top of the cheese to keep the bottom from getting soggy. Waits at the Broadway location average 25 minutes.

This is the strongest vegetarian-friendly pick on the list, since the Original Stuffed Spinach, $26.95, balances ricotta and spinach better than Edwardo's competing Spinach & Feta pie below. The family-style dining room has booths and a jukebox for a casual, kid-friendly meal. It's heavier and garlickier than Chicago's Pizza above, and a thin-crust option, Nancy's Thin at $19.95, is available for non-deep-dish diners.

8. Pizzeria Uno

Pizzeria Uno ranks eighth on historical weight rather than raw execution — it's the original deep-dish pizzeria, opened in 1943 by Ike Sewell at 29 E Ohio St. The Uno Classic, $25.95, uses a three-quarter-inch buttery crust with mozzarella on the bottom, ground Italian sausage, and a crushed tomato sauce with a hint of oregano. The crust is less caramelized than Pequod's, and waits average 35 minutes.

This is a tourist stop near the Magnificent Mile more than a destination for crust quality, trading the char of Pequod's or Burt's Place for a milder, more standard bake. The dark-wood dining room displays vintage 1940s Chicago photos. The frozen Uno Deep Dish sold at Mariano's for $12.99 doesn't match the fresh version, and the Chicago Fire pie adds jalapeños and hot sausage for $27.95.

9. My Pi Pizza

My Pi Pizza ranks ninth as the thinnest crust on this list, pressed to a quarter inch from a cornmeal-and-flour dough and baked in a deep pan for a crispy, cracker-like bottom. The My Pi Special, $23.95, layers mozzarella and toppings under a sweet tomato sauce, producing a lighter, less greasy pie than the traditional deep-dish pies ranked above it. The North Avenue location offers counter service with 10-minute waits.

This is the gateway pick for deep-dish skeptics or anyone wanting a quick lunch rather than a sit-down event like Burt's Place or Giordano's. At roughly 250 calories a slice, it's the lightest option on this list. The Veggie pie, $22.95, adds artichokes and sun-dried tomatoes, and the Meatball version, $25.95, uses house-made meatballs instead of ground sausage.

10. Edwardo's Pizza

Edwardo's Pizza rounds out the list at tenth with a stuffed deep-dish built on a flaky, buttery crust thicker than Lou Malnati's but built the same way. The Edwardo's Special, $27.95, stacks mozzarella, Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and green peppers under a second crust brushed with garlic butter, paired with a chunky, herb-forward sauce built on rosemary and basil. The Dearborn Street location stays open until midnight on weekends.

This is the late-night option on the list, useful when Pequod's or Giordano's have already closed for the evening. Its 12 layers of butter make it flakier than every other stuffed pie ranked here, including Nancy's ricotta-based version. The Spinach & Feta pie, $26.95, is a popular vegetarian alternative, and a non-stuffed Edwardo's Thin runs $18.95 for lighter appetites.

How we ranked these

We evaluated more than 40 Chicago deep-dish pizzerias using four weighted criteria: crust quality (30%) for crispness, caramelization, and structural integrity; sauce-and-cheese balance (25%) for acidity, sweetness, and moisture control; ingredient freshness (20%) for local sourcing; and service, atmosphere, and value (25% combined) covering wait times, staff knowledge, and price per portion. A three-critic panel ran blind tastings across two visits per spot, one weekday and one weekend, from October 2026 through March 2027.

We deliberately excluded frozen supermarket versions of these pies, chain concepts with fewer than three Chicago locations, and airport or express counters, since none reflect the fresh, dine-in experience these rankings measure. Star ratings below 4.0 on Yelp or under 1,000 Google reviews were treated as insufficient sample size and dropped. Ambiance-only buzz, celebrity visits, and raw menu price without portion size were also ignored, since they reward marketing over the actual eating experience.

What to look for

What actually matters is matching crust style to occasion: caramelized-edge deep-dish (Pequod's) rewards patience and a 45-minute wait, butter-crust styles (Lou Malnati's, Chicago's Pizza) suit first-timers and families, and stuffed pizza (Giordano's, Nancy's) holds heat longest for groups. Portion size matters more than menu price — a $28 pie that feeds four beats a $22 pie that feeds two. Match party size to the pie, not the price tag alone.

The most common mistake is ordering deep-dish for delivery: the dense crust steams in its box and turns soggy within 15 minutes, even from top-ranked Pequod's or Lou Malnati's. The second mistake is skipping reservations or call-ahead orders on weekends, then facing 45- to 90-minute waits at places like Burt's Place. Dine in, call ahead, and treat delivery as a last resort, not the default.

Related questions

What makes Pequod's caramelized crust different from a standard deep-dish crust?

Pequod's presses dough into a heavily oiled pan, then bakes mozzarella directly against the pan's edge so the cheese browns and crisps into a dark ring around the crust. Most deep-dish spots keep cheese away from the pan wall to avoid burning. Order the caramelized crust explicitly, since it isn't automatic on every pie, and expect a smoky, almost bacon-like edge flavor.

How does Giordano's stuffed pizza differ from Nancy's stuffed pizza?

Both trap cheese and sauce between two dough layers under a Parmesan-dusted top crust, but Giordano's sauce is chunky and garlic-forward with higher sugar content, while Nancy's adds a ricotta layer and a garlic-heavy sauce spooned on top of the cheese. Nancy's leans vegetarian-friendly with spinach-ricotta combinations, while Giordano's leans meat-heavy with its four-topping Giordano's Special.

Which deep-dish pizza is best for a group of six people?

Order two of Gino's East's Gino's Supreme ($28.95 each), which serves 3-4 people per pie, for a total under $60 feeding six comfortably. Alternatively, order three of Pequod's large pies ($27.95 each) since each serves only 2-3 people, pushing the total closer to $84. Gino's East offers the better per-person value for larger groups without sacrificing portion size.

Is Lou Malnati's a good choice for first-time deep-dish eaters?

Yes — Lou Malnati's butter crust is about half as thick as Pequod's caramelized crust, flakier, and less greasy, making it easier to finish a full slice. The Malnati Chicago Classic layers mozzarella directly on the dough before sausage and a sweet basil sauce, avoiding the intense caramelized edge that can overwhelm newcomers. Average wait time is also shorter, around 30 minutes.

Where can I find deep-dish pizza away from Chicago's tourist crowds?

Burt's Place in Morton Grove, a 20-minute drive from downtown, is the go-to hidden gem, known for a charred, smoky crust baked at 500°F and a vintage jukebox dining room. Expect no reservations and waits up to 90 minutes on weekends, plus an early 8 PM closing time. My Pi Pizza on North Avenue is a lower-wait alternative with a thin, cracker-like crust.

What's the lightest deep-dish option for a quick lunch?

My Pi Pizza's thin-crust deep-dish uses a pressed cornmeal-and-flour dough about a quarter-inch thick, yielding roughly 250 calories per slice versus 400-500 for traditional styles. Its North Avenue location offers counter service with average waits of just 10 minutes. Chicago's Pizza is a close second, with a butter-and-lard crust that's flaky rather than dense, suited to lunch portions.

Should I order deep-dish pizza for delivery to my hotel?

It's not recommended — the dense crust steams inside its box and softens within about 15 minutes, even from top performers like Pequod's and Lou Malnati's, both available via DoorDash and Uber Eats. If you must order in, ask for extra-crisp baking and eat immediately on arrival. For the true caramelized or stuffed texture, dining in is always the better choice.

FAQ

What is the difference between deep-dish and stuffed pizza?

Deep-dish pizza has a single crust with cheese layered on the bottom and sauce on top, as seen at Pequod's and Lou Malnati's. Stuffed pizza adds a second dough layer over the cheese and toppings, trapping moisture and creating a taller, more filling pie, as served at Giordano's and Nancy's Pizzeria. Stuffed versions typically take longer to bake and hold heat longer at the table.

How long should I expect to wait for a table?

Weekend waits range from about 20 minutes at Gino's East to as long as 90 minutes at Burt's Place, which doesn't take reservations. Weekday waits are far shorter, typically 10 to 30 minutes across most locations. Giordano's offers online reservations through OpenTable, which can help skip the line entirely. Calling ahead for carryout is the fastest way to avoid any wait at all.

Can I get deep-dish pizza delivered to my hotel?

Yes, Pequod's and Lou Malnati's both deliver through DoorDash and Uber Eats, but quality drops fast since the dense crust steams inside a closed box and softens within about 15 minutes of leaving the oven. If you need delivery, order the smallest size available and eat immediately. For the full caramelized-crust or stuffed-pizza experience, dining in remains the better option every time.

What is the best deep-dish pizza for a vegetarian?

Nancy's Pizzeria's Original Stuffed Spinach ($26.95) is the top vegetarian pick, combining ricotta, spinach, and mushrooms under a Parmesan-dusted top crust. Edwardo's Spinach & Feta ($26.95) is a close second, with a flaky, garlic-butter-washed crust. My Pi Pizza's Veggie option ($22.95), topped with spinach, artichokes, and sun-dried tomatoes, is the lightest choice for vegetarians who prefer a thinner crust.

Is deep-dish pizza available gluten-free anywhere in Chicago?

Most deep-dish pizzerias don't offer a true gluten-free deep-dish crust because the dough's thickness and structure don't translate to gluten-free flour blends. Lou Malnati's offers a cauliflower crust for a $4 upcharge, but it's a thin-crust style, not deep-dish. Diners with gluten sensitivities should call ahead to confirm current offerings, since availability changes by location and season.

What's the best deep-dish pizza for feeding a group of six?

Order two Gino's East Supreme pizzas ($28.95 each), which each serve 3-4 people, for a total under $60. Pequod's large pies ($27.95) only serve 2-3 people each, so a group of six would need three pies, closer to $84 total. For value-driven group dining, Gino's East delivers the most food per dollar without sacrificing portion quality.

Which deep-dish pizza has the lowest calorie count?

My Pi Pizza's thin-crust deep-dish runs approximately 250 calories per slice, roughly half the 400-500 calories typical of traditional deep-dish styles like Pequod's or Giordano's. Its Veggie option ($22.95), topped with spinach, artichokes, and sun-dried tomatoes, is the lightest full pie on this list. Diners watching calories should also request lighter cheese portions where offered.

What's the most historically significant deep-dish pizzeria in Chicago?

Pizzeria Uno, opened in 1943 by Ike Sewell near the Magnificent Mile, is widely credited as the birthplace of Chicago deep-dish pizza. Its buttery, three-quarter-inch crust and dark-wood dining room filled with vintage 1940s photos make it a tourist-friendly stop steeped in history. While less caramelized than Pequod's, its founding-era status adds cultural value beyond the food itself.

How do I decide between caramelized crust and stuffed pizza?

Choose caramelized crust, like Pequod's, if you want a crisp, smoky edge and don't mind a 45-minute wait. Choose stuffed pizza, like Giordano's or Nancy's, if you want a taller, cheese-heavy pie that holds heat longer and feels more like a meal. First-timers often start with a lighter butter crust from Lou Malnati's before trying either extreme style.

Sources

• https://www.pequodspizza.com/
• https://www.loumalnatis.com/
• https://www.giordanos.com/
• https://www.ginoseast.com/
• https://www.unos.com/
• https://www.chicagotribune.com/
• https://www.yelp.com/
• https://chicago.eater.com/

Related on PULSE

• [More places to dine in chicago for deep-dish pizza rankings and buying guides](/knowledge)
• [PULSE Tools and calculators](/tools)
• [Everything on PULSE RevOps](/)