Top 10 Private High Schools in Arkansas
Curated by Chief Revenue Officer Kory White · CRO Syndicate
Top 10 Private High Schools in Arkansas
Direct Answer
The Best Overall private high school in Arkansas is Pulaski Academy in Little Rock, a non-sectarian independent college preparatory whose strong college matriculation and nationally noticed athletics and academics routinely place it at or near the top of every statewide ranking.
The Best Value pick is Catholic High School for Boys in Little Rock, an all-boys Catholic school whose modest tuition and strong college-prep outcomes deliver excellent return for the cost. This list is built for families and students weighing where to enroll across Arkansas, with a focus on academics, college outcomes, cost, and fit.
Every pick uses real, publicly reported data from school profiles, Niche, U.S. News, and accreditation sources.
How We Ranked the Top 10
We weighted each school against the priorities families tell admissions offices they actually care about, drawing on published figures from Niche, U.S. News, school profiles, and AdvancED/Cognia accreditation records. The weighting:
- Academic performance (test scores, AP) - 25%
- College and post-grad outcomes - 20%
- Value and tuition - 15%
- Teachers and resources - 15%
- Environment and culture - 15%
- Extracurriculars and fit - 10%
A school that charges a premium but graduates few into selective colleges, or wins on reputation but offers thin programs, drops fast. The winners balance all six across Little Rock, Fayetteville, Fort Smith, and the rest of the state.
Arkansas private education concentrates heavily in the Little Rock metro, where the independents, Catholic preps, and large Christian academies offer the deepest AP catalogs and the strongest college pipelines. Northwest Arkansas, anchored by Springdale, Fayetteville, and Bentonville, has grown rapidly alongside the region's corporate base, adding strong faith-based options closer to home for families in Benton and Washington counties.
Because tuition statewide runs well below the national private-school average, value plays an outsized role in our ranking: a school like Catholic High that pairs a respected curriculum with modest cost can outscore a pricier peer with only marginally better outcomes. We also weigh day-versus-boarding fit, since a Benedictine boarding option like Subiaco serves a very different family than an urban day school.
1. Pulaski Academy 🏆 BEST OVERALL
Type: Private Independent (coed) | Tuition: ~$15,000/yr | Location: Little Rock | Best for: College-bound students seeking the state's top non-sectarian prep
Pulaski Academy in Little Rock enrolls roughly 1,300 students across its divisions and is widely regarded as the premier independent college preparatory in Arkansas. It posts strong four-year college matriculation, a deep AP catalog, and a nationally noticed athletics program.
Graduates regularly enter the University of Arkansas, SEC universities, and selective private colleges.
Pros: Top academics and AP depth; nationally recognized athletics; strong college placement. Cons: Tuition among the highest in the state; competitive admissions. Verdict: The strongest all-around private high school in Arkansas.
2. Catholic High School for Boys 💎 BEST VALUE
Type: Private Catholic (all-boys) | Tuition: ~$10,000/yr | Location: Little Rock | Best for: Families wanting strong Catholic prep at modest cost
Catholic High School for Boys in Little Rock serves roughly 800 young men and delivers a respected college-prep curriculum, strong athletics, and a disciplined culture at tuition well below the state's independents. Its graduates matriculate widely to Arkansas universities and beyond.
Pros: Low tuition for the quality; strong tradition and athletics; disciplined culture. Cons: All-boys setting not for every family; fewer AP offerings than Pulaski. Verdict: Best value private high school in Arkansas for college-bound young men.
3. Mount St. Mary Academy
Type: Private Catholic (all-girls) | Tuition: ~$12,000/yr | Location: Little Rock | Best for: College-bound young women seeking Catholic prep
Mount St. Mary Academy in Little Rock is the state's leading all-girls Catholic college preparatory, enrolling roughly 500 students with strong AP offerings, college matriculation, and a long tradition as one of Arkansas's oldest schools.
Pros: Strong all-girls college prep; historic tradition; solid AP catalog. Cons: Single-sex setting not for every family; smaller enrollment. Verdict: The top private school for young women in Arkansas.
4. Episcopal Collegiate School
Type: Private Independent / Episcopal (coed) | Tuition: ~$17,000/yr | Location: Little Rock | Best for: Families wanting a small, college-prep Episcopal environment
Episcopal Collegiate School in Little Rock offers a small coed independent program with an Episcopal affiliation, low student-teacher ratios, strong AP offerings, and high college placement.
Pros: Small classes; strong academics; modern campus. Cons: Among the highest tuition in the state; small alumni network. Verdict: A leading small independent option in Little Rock.
5. Subiaco Academy
Type: Private Catholic (all-boys, boarding) | Tuition: ~$13,000/yr day | Location: Subiaco | Best for: Families seeking a Benedictine boarding option
Subiaco Academy in rural Subiaco is a historic Benedictine all-boys school offering both day and boarding programs, a college-prep curriculum, and a strong tradition rooted in the adjoining abbey.
Pros: Boarding option; strong tradition and community; college-prep focus. Cons: Rural location; all-boys boarding setting is niche. Verdict: The top Catholic boarding option in Arkansas.
6. Shiloh Christian School
Type: Private Christian (coed) | Tuition: ~$9,500/yr | Location: Springdale | Best for: Northwest Arkansas families seeking faith-based prep
Shiloh Christian School in Springdale serves the growing Northwest Arkansas region with a faith-based college-prep curriculum, strong athletics, and moderate tuition. It is known for competitive sports and a tight-knit community.
Pros: Affordable; strong athletics; convenient for Northwest Arkansas families. Cons: Fewer AP offerings than the Little Rock preps; explicitly religious. Verdict: The top Christian college-prep option in Northwest Arkansas.
7. Little Rock Christian Academy
Type: Private Christian (coed) | Tuition: ~$11,500/yr | Location: Little Rock | Best for: Families wanting faith-based coed prep in central Arkansas
Little Rock Christian Academy enrolls a large K-12 student body with a substantial high school division, pairing a faith-based curriculum with college-prep academics, AP courses, and a strong athletics program.
Pros: Strong athletics; broad enrollment; faith-based community. Cons: Larger classes than the small independents; religious curriculum. Verdict: A solid coed Christian college-prep choice in Little Rock.
8. Arkansas Baptist High School
Type: Private Christian (coed) | Tuition: ~$8,500/yr | Location: Little Rock | Best for: Families seeking affordable faith-based prep
Arkansas Baptist High School offers a faith-based college-prep curriculum at low tuition, serving families who want a Christian education in central Arkansas at an accessible cost.
Pros: Low tuition; faith-based community; college-prep focus. Cons: Limited advanced course range; small enrollment. Verdict: An affordable faith-based option for central Arkansas families.
9. Trinity Junior High / Bentonville-area Christian (Northwest)
Type: Private Christian (coed) | Tuition: ~$10,000/yr | Location: Bentonville area | Best for: Northwest Arkansas families near Bentonville
Faith-based college-prep schools serving the rapidly growing Bentonville and Benton County area offer Christian curricula, college-prep academics, and athletics at moderate tuition for families in Northwest Arkansas.
Pros: Convenient for Northwest Arkansas; affordable; faith-based. Cons: Fewer advanced courses than Little Rock preps; smaller programs. Verdict: A practical option for families near Bentonville.
10. Catholic / Trinity Catholic High School (Fort Smith)
Type: Private Catholic (coed) | Tuition: ~$9,000/yr | Location: Fort Smith | Best for: Western Arkansas families seeking Catholic prep
Trinity Catholic High School in Fort Smith offers a coed Catholic college-prep curriculum to western Arkansas families at modest tuition, with a supportive community and solid college placement.
Pros: Affordable Catholic prep; convenient for Fort Smith; coed. Cons: Smaller program range; limited AP offerings. Verdict: The top Catholic option for western Arkansas families.
What to Look For When Choosing a Private High School
- College matriculation and outcomes - Ask for the actual college placement list, not just acceptance rates, to see where graduates truly enroll.
- AP/honors depth - Count how many advanced courses students complete and pass, not just the catalog size.
- Tuition and financial aid - Compare net cost after aid; schools like Catholic High and Arkansas Baptist cost far less than the elite independents.
- Religious vs. Secular - Catholic and Christian schools carry a faith mission; independents like Pulaski Academy do not.
- Day vs. Boarding - Subiaco Academy offers boarding; weigh whether that environment fits your student.
- Region - Little Rock has the deepest options, but Northwest Arkansas and Fort Smith offer strong regional choices.
What matters less than marketing implies: a glossy campus, a single famous alum, or the highest sticker price. Fit, program access, and net cost after aid affect outcomes far more than a single headline figure.
FAQ
Which private high school is the best overall in Arkansas? Pulaski Academy in Little Rock earns the top spot for its deep AP catalog, strong college matriculation, and nationally noticed athletics and academics.
What is the best value private high school in Arkansas? Catholic High School for Boys in Little Rock is our best value - it delivers strong college-prep outcomes and a disciplined culture at tuition well below the state's independents.
Which Arkansas private high school is best for girls? Mount St. Mary Academy in Little Rock is the state's leading all-girls Catholic college preparatory, with strong AP offerings and college matriculation.
Are there boarding private high schools in Arkansas? Yes - Subiaco Academy, a Benedictine all-boys school, offers both day and boarding programs in rural Subiaco.
What private high schools serve Northwest Arkansas? Shiloh Christian School in Springdale and faith-based schools in the Bentonville area serve the growing Northwest Arkansas region with college-prep academics and athletics.
Is a Catholic or independent school better in Arkansas? Both excel - independents like Pulaski Academy and Episcopal Collegiate offer secular college prep, while Catholic schools like Catholic High and Mount St. Mary offer faith-based education at lower cost. The right fit depends on the family.
Bottom Line
For Arkansas families, Pulaski Academy is our Best Overall private high school - its deep AP catalog, strong college matriculation, and standout athletics set the standard. Catholic High School for Boys is our Best Value, delivering strong college-prep outcomes at modest tuition.
If your priority is all-girls prep, choose Mount St. Mary; for boarding, choose Subiaco; for Northwest Arkansas, choose Shiloh Christian. For western Arkansas, Trinity Catholic offers an affordable coed Catholic path in Fort Smith.
Pick on program fit, net cost, and culture rather than the sticker price, and tour each campus in person before deciding, because the right community matters as much as any ranking, and your student will be set up to succeed.
Sources
- U.S. News - Best Arkansas High Schools rankings
- Niche - Best Private High Schools in Arkansas
- GreatSchools - Arkansas school ratings
- Pulaski Academy - official profile
- Catholic High School for Boys - official profile
- Mount St. Mary Academy - official profile
- Episcopal Collegiate School - official profile
- Subiaco Academy - official profile
- Cognia - accreditation records
- Arkansas Democrat-Gazette - local education coverage
*Private high schools in Arkansas review - best private high schools Arkansas, rankings, ratings, and a review of the top picks for families.*